![]() |
Pneumatic Boot Therapies
History Suction-Pressure Boots, Physics and Lessons for Modern Boot Therapy
Circulator Boot versus EECP/ECP
Vascular Physiology Often Ignored and Vector Analysis of Leg Forces in Pneumatic Compression Treatments
Circulator Boot and Topical Oxygen Therapy
The Art of Boot Therapy - A Summary
The Story of the Circulator Boot at Bryn Mawr by Richard S.Dillon MD:The Circulator Boot - Medicare, Bureaucratic Medicine and Uninformed Consensus - It Won't Happen in My Family - A Personal Story.
Available at the publisher: https://www.createspace.com/3577899 or Amazon.com.
Abstracts
- Abu-Own A, Cheatle T, Scurr JH, and Smith PDC:
Effects of intermittent pneumatic compression of the foot on the
microcirculatory function in arterial disease. Eur J Vasc
Surg 7: 488-492, 1993. Abstract: The venous pump of the foot
assists blood returning to the heart. The aim of this study was to
evaluate the effect of mechanical activation of the foot pump on
the microcirculation of the skin in patients with peripheral
occlusive arterial disease. Design: single parallel group comparing
patients with arterial disease to normal control subjects. Setting:
Department of Surgery, the University College and Middlesex
Hospital, London, U.K. Subjects and materials: 15 patients with
occlusive arterial disease and 15 control subjects. A pneumatic
impulse foot pump was applied to the foot. Outcome measures: the
Laser Doppler flux (LDF) and transcutaneous oxygen tension (tcPO2 )
were measured on the big toe with the subject supine, before,
during and after a 10 min period of foot pumping. The study was
repeated with the subject sitting. Results: on sitting there is a
fall in LDF and a rise in tcPO2. Application of intermittent
pneumatic compression of the foot in the sitting position resulted
in an increase in LDF. In patients, the median percentage increase
was 57% and the median difference was 82 arbitrary units (AU)(95%CI
60-130, p< 0.001). In controls, the median percentage increase
was 66% and the median difference was 124 AU (95%CI 73-275 p <
0.001). There was a corresponding "further" increase in tcPO2 in
both groups of subjects. In patients, the median percentage
increase was 8%, in controls the median percentage increase was 10%
p < 0.01). Conclusion: we conclude that intermittent pneumatic
compression of the foot in the dependent position increases. LDF
and tcPO2 Comments: The authors used a mini-pump limited to the
foot. They did not pump on the diseased areas of the calf and thigh
and they pumped but a brief time (10 minutes) and the effect on LDF
was brief fading "away within 20s of stopping the foot pump". Here
they are reporting on LDF and tcPO2. Allwood (Clin Sc 16:231, 1957)
pumped on the lower calf and documented an increase in blood flow
in the foot with a plethysmographic method. Loan ( J Appl Physiol
14(3): 411-413, 1959) rhythmically inflated a cuff around the ankle
in the seated position and noted an increase in blood flow in the
foot by three methods: venous occlusion plethysmography, heat flow
and calorimetry. Henry and Winsor (Am Heart J 70:79-88, 1965)
pumped from the head of the fibula to the malleoli and documented
increased flow in the foot by measuring falloff in counts from
injected I131. Gaskell and Parrott (Surg Gyn & Obstet
146:583-592, 1978) pumped on the foot and ankle and documented an
increased clearance of 133 Xe from the dorsum of the foot. See Eze,
Comerota et al below for more recent work with
non-cardiosynchronous calf and foot pumps.
- Agerskov K, Tofft HP, Jensen FB, Engell HC:
External negative thigh pressure. Effect upon blood flow and
pressure in the foot in patients with occlusive arterial
disease. Dan Med Bull 37:451-4, 1990. We studied the effect
of external application of 35-45 mmHg negative pressure around the
thigh on toe blood pressure and skin blood flow in nine patients
with occlusion of the superficial femoral artery and rest
pain/severe intermittent claudication. The systolic toe blood
pressure increased from 32 (range 5-70) mmHg before treatment to 57
(42-75) mmHg (p less than 0.05) during negative thigh pressure and
44 (range 10-88) mmHg after treatment. In addition, the gain in toe
blood pressure tended to be greater the lower the pre-test toe
pressure was, correlation coefficient r = 0.52 (p greater than
0.05). Relative skin blood flow, measured in the first toe
interstice by the 133Xe wash-out method, increased by 304 (range
86-767) percent (p less than 0.05) during the test period compared
to the mean wash-out rate obtained before and following the test
period. Heart rate, systemic blood pressure, skin temperature,
serum protein and haematocrit measured during each phase of the
study were similar. We conclude that 35-45 mmHg negative pressure
around the thigh in patients with occlusion of the superficial
femoral artery induce increased blood perfusion in the foot,
possibly due to changes in collateral arterial resistance in the
thigh. Comments: The suction-pressure boots in use in the 1930's
utilized alternating negative pressure and positive pressure in the
supine position. An air seal, of course, is necessary in the upper
thigh in such boots and the alternation in negative and positive
pressure resulted in considerable shear forces at the air seal; the
treatment was stressful to both the skin and underlying tissue.
Thirty mm Hg is equivalent to about 17 inches of water pressure,
about the distance from the aortic valve to the midthigh in the
sitting position. Merely by sitting up during therapy with the
Circulator Long-Boot, one gains the benefits of gravity and an
equivalent of about 30 mm Hg negative pressure. The treatment is
well tolerated and no skin breakdown occurs.
- Alpagut U, Dayioglu E: Importance and advantages
of intermittent external pneumatic compression therapy in venous
stasis ulceration. Angiology. 56:19-23, 2005. Venous ulcers
are seen following postthrombophlebitic syndrome with venous
insufficiency and can begin as a result of minor trauma. In this
retrospective study the authors examined the value of external
intermittent pneumatic compression therapy in chronic venous
ulcers. Results in 1,250 patients with postthrombophlebitic
syndromes, 235 of these patients with leg ulcers, revealed that
this modality of therapy shortens the therapy duration, lowers the
total therapy cost, and hastens the return to active life in
comparison to the classical therapy with compression stockings and
antiaggregant or low-dose oral anticoagulant therapy. In the light
of their findings they propose the wider use of this adjuvant
therapy.
- Amsterdam EA, Lee G, Tonkon MJ, DeMaria AN and Mason DT:
Noninvasive circulatory assistance by external
counterpulsation. Chapter 14 in Advances In Heart Disease,
Volume I, Mason DT editor. Grune & Stratton New York, 1977. The
duration of applied pressure was approximately 250 msec. In normal
subjects diastolic blood pressure was elevated 40-70% and cardiac
output increased 15-60% during the treatment. Treatment of angina
patients for one hour daily for 5 days resulted in symptomatic
improvement in 17 of 21 individuals with definitely improved
angiograms in 5 of 11 and equivocally improved angiograms in 4 of
the 11 patients undergoing coronary angiography. An increased
vascularity was seen in the angiograms.
- Applebaum RM, Kasliwal R, Tunick PA, Konecky N, Katz ES,
Trehan N and Kronzon I: Sequential external
counterpulsation increases cerebral and renal blood flow. Am
Heart J 133: 611-615, 1997. Abstract: The purpose of this study was
to evaluate the effect of sequential external counterpulsation
(SECP) on cerebral and renal blood flow. The effect of SECP on
carotid and renal artery blood flow was studied in 35 and 18
patients, respectively. With a portable unit, cuffs were applied to
the calves and thighs, sequentially inflated with air at the onset
of diastole and deflated at the onset of systole. Carotid and renal
Duplex studies were performed during intermittent SECP. Diastolic
augmentation of carotid and renal artery flow velocity was observed
in all patients. The mean carotid flow integral increased by 22%
from 27.7 ± 1.8 cm to 33.1 ± 2.3cm (P=0.001). The
mean renal artery flow velocity integral increased by 19% from 21
± 1 cm to 25 ± 1 cm (P=0.0001). With SECP, a new
diastolic Doppler flow velocity wave was observed was observed,
with an average peak carotid diastolic flow velocity of 56 ±
4 cm/sec and an average peak renal artery diastolic flow velocity
of 40 ± 2.5 cm/sec. This diastolic wave was 75% (carotid)
and 68% (renal) as high as the systolic wave during SECP. In
addition, with SECP the systolic wave increased 6% and 8% in the
carotid and renal artery, respectively (P=0.02 and 0.006
respectively). In conclusion, SECP significantly increases carotid
and renal blood flow. This noninvasive, harmless treatment may be
useful to support patients with decreased cerebral and renal
perfusion. Comment: Case 32 on this website demonstrates what
these techniques may accomplish in diabetics with chronic renal
failure. But is the treatment described in this article harmless?
The ECP devices are generally contraindicated in the presence of
leg ischemia. Consideration of the standard reactive hyperemia test
in the vascular laboratory is helpful in understanding why. A cuff
is placed around the upper thigh for a few minutes and released and
the time required for the pulse wave to return to the ankle noted.
No blood was delivered to the muscles of the thigh and calf during
the placement of the cuff and anoxia of these tissues develops.
When the cuff is removed in patients with arteriosclerotic lesions,
the metabolic needs of the proximal tissues are met before the
blood flow reaches more distal tissues. In a normal leg with an
open conduit between the thigh and distal pulse, the distal pulse
is quickly detected and the metabolic needs of the leg may be met
more simultaneously. In the abnormal leg, however, it may take
minutes before the distal pulse is detected. The pulse in the
normal leg may be likened to a line of balls on a pool table;
hitting one end with the Q-ball will knock a single ball off the
end of the line of balls. In the normal leg, there is a column of
blood from the heart to the groin and from there to the foot. The
pulse wave is transmitted through this column of blood. If the leg
is compressed with a bag containing pressure higher than the
systolic pressure in the leg, the arterial blood is pressed
backward towards the heart and the column of blood from the groin
to the foot is gone. Restoration of the pulse at the ankle then
requires not only meeting the metabolic needs of the proximal
tissue but restoration of the column of blood from the groin to the
ankle. Especially, in patients with peripheral arteriosclerotic
lesions, the column of blood from the groin to the ankle is not
continuous and fills slowly. It is apparent that the application of
pressure to the leg that is greater than the systolic pressure at
some level in the leg may produce distal ischemia. Even if the
application of pressure is brief as in the ECP device, ischemia can
and is produced in patients with peripheral vascular disease. If
the application of pressure is longer, the pressure then blocks
inflow of blood while it is applied. Thus, in the situation where a
cuff is applied for a few seconds round the calf at a pressure
higher than systolic pressure, a few beats are blocked from
entering the calf while venous blood may be expressed from the
tissue. Release of such a cuff, of course, will be associated with
a brief surge of blood down the popliteal artery until it meets the
first arterial lesion where it then is not further assisted. In
contrast to these situations, the Circulator Boot compresses the
leg with diastolic pressure and is so applied that a normally
pressurized portion of the leg is included. Inflation of the
Circulator Boot does not push blood out of the normally pressurized
segment. Each pulse wave is allowed to enter the leg as best it
can. The Circulator Boot then provides a compression both expelling
the venous blood and providing a driving force to disseminate the
arterial blood around the leg (much as one disseminates water
around a sponge that it half wet when one squeezes it). If the
heart rate is rapid and there is a question as to whether the time
for blood inflow is too short, the Circulator Boot heart monitor
signals to the operator to switch to 2:1 or 3:1 settings thus
allowing one or two extra pulse waves to enter the leg before leg
compressions. These timing considerations remain unique to the
Circulator Boot systems and allow our successful treatment of
ischemic legs. The rapid action of the Circulator Boot systems
allows for the elaboration of endothelial factors as mentioned in
our library on vascular hormone and clotting factors. Again, as
noted below, we show the importance of these considerations in our
commentary on the article by Eze AR et al.
- Akhtar M, Wu G-F, Du Z-M, Zheng Z-S, Michaels ADAm J Cardiol 98:28-30, 2006. Enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) significantly augments diastolic blood flow and has been postulated to improve endothelial function by increased shear stress. We examined the effects of EECP on plasma nitric oxide and endothelin-1 (ET-1) levels. Plasma nitrate and nitrite (NOx) and ET-1 levels were measured serially in 13 patients with coronary artery disease who received 1-hour daily treatments of EECP over 6 weeks. During the course of EECP therapy, plasma NOx progressively increased and plasma ET-1 progressively decreased. After 36 hours of EECP, there was a 62 ± 17% increase in plasma NOx compared with baseline (43.6 ± 4.3 vs 27.1 ± 2.6 µmol/L, p <0.0001) and a 36 ± 8% decrease in plasma ET-1 (76.7 ± 9.5 vs 119.5 ± 8.5 pg/L, p <0.0001). At 3 months after completion of EECP, NOx remained 12 ± 11% above baseline (p = 0.002), and ET-1 remained 11 ± 10% below baseline (p = 0.0068). Our data provides neurohormonal evidence to support the hypothesis that EECP improves endothelial function.
- Bergan JJ, Sparks S, Angle N: A Comparison of Compression Pumps in the Treatment of Lymphedema. Vascular and Endovascular Surgery 32:455-462, 1998. Purpose: This study was done in order to ascertain which methods of mechanical compression would be optimum in treating patients with primary and secondary lymphedema.
Materials and Methods: Thirty-five patients (26 women, 9 men) were enrolled in the study. The women ranged in age from 36 to 82 years (mean 56.9 years). The men ranged in age from 31 to 83 years (mean 56.4 years). Ultimately, 32 patients completed the study. Each patient was treated by random assignment to each of the three types of compression pumps. The treatment arms were as follows: (1) unicompartmental nongradient pump with pressure of 50 mm Hg, (2) a three-compartment pump with segmental, nongradient pressures of 50 mm Hg in each of three cells, and (3) a multicompartmental gradient pressure pump with ten cells ranging in pressure from 80 at the most distal to 30 at the most proximal. There were 35 extremities treated by each of the three methods. Eleven had primary lymphedema and 24 had secondary lymphedema.
Results: The mean percentage volume change was +0.4% in the limbs treated with the unicompartmental pump, +7.3% in the three-compartment pump, and -32.6% in the ten-compartment pump. By use of Kruskal and Wallis, one-way ANOVA on ranks, a significant difference between the three treatments was detected (p < 0.001). In treatment of primary lymphedema there was no difference between the subgroups with regard to the effect of the three compression pumps. In treatment of secondary lymphedema, there was no reduction in the size of the limbs treated with the single-compartment, there was a -4.65% reduction in the three-compartment pump treatment, and -28.4% in the tencompartment pump. There were no differences in treatment of secondary limbs with and without radiation. In an analysis comparing primary to secondary lymphedema with and without radiation, the results were not statistically different from one another. Other factors such as severity of lymphedema, gender, duration of lymphedema, history of infection, and presence of radiation could not be implicated as having prognostic significance or having any effect on response to therapy.
Conclusions: Mechanical external pneumatic compression can produce a reduction in treated limb volumes in primary and secondary lymphedema. This is best achieved by multicompartment sequential compression. Limb volume reduction by single or three compartment devices is decidedly less effective in treatment of lymphedema.
- Blackshear WM, Pescott C, LePain F, Benoit S, Dickstein R,
Seifert KB: Influence of sequential pneumatic compression
of postoperative venous function. J Vasc Surg 5:432-6, 1987.
Venous capacitance decreased from an ambulatory preoperative state
(3.19(0.43cc/100 cc tissue) to the postoperative state of complete
bedrest (2.08(0.34). Likewise, venous outflow decreased from
87.2(10.6 to 58.1(8.7 cc/100cc of tissue/min. When legs were pumped
postoperatively with a sequential pneumatic device, the falloff was
significantly less. The authors hypothesized that the improvement
in venous function was induced by the direct mechanical effects of
pumping on the vessel wall, humoral or neurogenic factors, or a
Venturi effect through increased flow velocity in the vena
cava.
- Bolli R, Marbán E: Molecular and cellular mechanisms of myocardial stunning. Physiol Rev 79:609-34, 1999. The past two decades have witnessed an explosive growth of knowledge regarding postischemic myocardial dysfunction or myocardial "stunning." The purpose of this review is to summarize current information regarding the pathophysiology and pathogenesis of this phenomenon. Myocardial stunning should not be regarded as a single entity but rather as a "syndrome" that has been observed in a wide variety of experimental settings, which include the following: 1) stunning after a single, completely reversible episode of regional ischemia in vivo; 2) stunning after multiple, completely reversible episodes of regional ischemia in vivo; 3) stunning after a partly reversible episode of regional ischemia in vivo (subendocardial infarction); 4) stunning after global ischemia in vitro; 5) stunning after global ischemia in vivo; and 6) stunning after exercise-induced ischemia (high-flow ischemia). Whether these settings share a common mechanism is unknown. Although the pathogenesis of myocardial stunning has not been definitively established, the two major hypotheses are that it is caused by the generation of oxygen-derived free radicals (oxyradical hypothesis) and by a transient calcium overload (calcium hypothesis) on reperfusion. The final lesion responsible for the contractile depression appears to be a decreased responsiveness of contractile filaments to calcium. Recent evidence suggests that calcium overload may activate calpains, resulting in selective proteolysis of myofibrils; the time required for resynthesis of damaged proteins would explain in part the delayed recovery of function in stunned myocardium. The oxyradical and calcium hypotheses are not mutually exclusive and are likely to represent different facets of the same pathophysiological cascade. For example, increased free radical formation could cause cellular calcium overload, which would damage the contractile apparatus of the myocytes. Free radical generation could also directly alter contractile filaments in a manner that renders them less responsive to calcium (e.g., oxidation of critical thiol groups). However, it remains unknown whether oxyradicals play a role in all forms of stunning and whether the calcium hypothesis is applicable to stunning in vivo. Nevertheless, it is clear that the lesion responsible for myocardial stunning occurs, at least in part, after reperfusion so that this contractile dysfunction can be viewed, in part, as a form of "reperfusion injury." An important implication of the phenomenon of myocardial stunning is that so-called chronic hibernation may in fact be the result of repetitive episodes of stunning, which have a cumulative effect and cause protracted postischemic dysfunction. A better understanding of myocardial stunning will expand our knowledge of the pathophysiology of myocardial ischemia and provide a rationale for developing new therapeutic strategies designed to prevent postischemic dysfunction in patients.Comments: Postoperative heart surgery disasters are usually treated with the aortic balloon which has a signifiant morbidity (http://www.circulatorboot.com/Newsletter/vol2numb3.html). In our Case 182, the balloon was associated with the development of significant leg ischemia and had to be discontinued. The use of the Circulator Boot not only restored blood flow to both legs but also benefited his heart (http://www.circulatorboot.com/casehistory/case182.html).
- Bondesson S, Pettersson Tet al: Effects on blood pressure in patients with refractory angina pectoris after enhanced external counterpulsation. Blood Press April, 2010, Abstract: Objective. Enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) is a non-invasive technique that has been shown to reduce the frequency and severity of angina pectoris. Little is known how EECP affects the blood pressure. Methods. 153 patients with refractory angina were treated with either EECP or retained on their pharmacological treatment (reference group). Systolic blood pressure (SBP), diastolic blood pressure (DBP), mean arterial blood pressure (MAP) and heart rate were measured pre- and post-treatment and at 12 months follow-up. Results. EECP treatment altered the blood pressure in patients with refractory angina pectoris. A decrease in the blood pressure was more common in the EECP group compared with the reference group. In the reference group, an increase in the blood pressure was more common. A correlation between a decrease in blood pressure after EECP treatment and a higher baseline MAP, SBP and DBP was seen. No such correlation was seen in the reference group. The blood pressure response did not persist at 12 months follow-up. Conclusion. EECP treatment affects the blood pressure in patients with refractory angina pectoris. The decreased blood pressure may be a result of an improved exercise capacity, an improved endothelial function and vasoreactivity in general.Comments: Hypertension as been said to be associated with an element of heart failure in that the heart may tire pumping against increased periperal vascular resistance. Circulator Boot therapy rests the heart allowing it to tackle the vascular resistance with increased vigor once each therapy is over. To treat this phenomenon, one can transiently increase the anti-hypertension of the patient. Thus, if the patient is taking Diovan 40mg three times a day, 80mg might be given after the treatment and the blood pressure with a home sphygmomanometer. The EECP devices are designed to elevate the dicrotic notch (the point of closure of the aortic valve) as evidence of cardiac-assist. Unfortunately, this increases terminal systolic heart work. End-disatolic pumping does not do this.
- Bonetti PO, Holmes DR Jr, Lerman A, Barsness GW: Enhanced external counterpulsation for ischemic heart disease: what's behind the curtain? J Am Coll Cardiol 41:1918-25. 2003. Enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) has been shown to reduce angina and to improve objective measures of myocardial ischemia in patients with refractory angina. Prospective clinical studies and large treatment registries suggest that a course of EECP is associated with prolongation of the time to exercise-induced ST-segment depression and resolution of myocardial perfusion defects, as well as with enhanced exercise tolerance and quality of life. With a growing knowledge base supporting the safety and beneficial clinical effects associated with EECP, this therapy can be considered a valuable treatment option, particularly in patients who have exhausted traditional revascularization methods and yet remain symptomatic despite optimal medical care. However, although the concept of external counterpulsation was introduced almost four decades ago, and despite growing evidence supporting the clinical benefit and safety of this therapeutic modality, little is firmly established regarding the mechanisms responsible for the beneficial effects associated with this technique. Suggested mechanisms contributing to the clinical benefit of EECP include improvement in endothelial function, promotion of coronary collateralization, enhancement of ventricular function, peripheral effects similar to those observed with regular physical exercise, and nonspecific placebo effects. This review summarizes the current evidence for a contribution of these mechanisms to the clinical benefit associated with EECP.
- Bonetti PO, Barsness GW, Keelan PC et al: Enhanced external counterpulsation improves endothelial function in patients with symptomatic coronary artery disease. J Am Coll Cardiol 41:1761-1768, 2003. Abstract: OBJECTIVES: The goal of this study was to examine the effect of enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) on endothelial function. BACKGROUND: Enhanced external counterpulsation improves symptoms and exercise tolerance in patients with symptomatic coronary artery disease (CAD). However, the exact mechanisms by which this technique exerts its clinical benefit are unclear. METHODS: Reactive hyperemia-peripheral arterial tonometry (RH-PAT), a noninvasive method to assess peripheral endothelial function by measuring reactive hyperemic response in the finger, was performed in 23 patients with refractory angina undergoing a 35-h course of EECP. In each patient RH-PAT measurements were performed before and after the first, at midcourse, and the last EECP session. In addition, RH-PAT response was assessed one month after completion of EECP therapy; RH-PAT index, a measure of reactive hyperemia, was calculated as the ratio of the digital pulse volume during reactive hyperemia divided by that at rest. RESULTS: Enhanced external counterpulsation led to symptomatic improvement (?1 Canadian Cardiovascular Society class) in 17 (74%) patients; EECP was associated with a significant immediate increase in average RH-PAT index after each treatment (p < 0.05). In addition, average RH-PAT index at one-month follow-up was significantly higher than that before EECP therapy (p < 0.05). When patients were divided by their clinical response, RH-PAT index at one-month follow-up increased only in those patients who experienced clinical benefit. CONCLUSIONS: Enhanced external counterpulsation enhances peripheral endothelial function with beneficial effects persisting at one-month follow-up in patients with a positive clinical response. This suggests that improvement in endothelial function may contribute to the clinical benefit of EECP in patients with symptomatic CAD.
- Braith RW, Conti CR, Nichols WW, et al Enhanced External Counterpulsation Improves Peripheral Artery Flow-Mediated Dilation in Patients With Chronic Angina. A Randomized Sham-Controlled Study. Circulation. 2010 Oct 4. BACKGROUND: -Mechanisms responsible for anti-ischemic benefits of enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) remain unknown. This was the first randomized sham-controlled study to investigate the extracardiac effects of EECP on peripheral artery flow-mediated dilation. Methods and Results-Forty-two symptomatic patients with coronary artery disease were randomized (2:1 ratio) to thirty-five 1-hour sessions of either EECP (n=28) or sham EECP (n=14). Flow-mediated dilation of the brachial and femoral arteries was performed with the use of ultrasound. Plasma levels of nitrate and nitrite, 6-keto-prostaglandin F1a, endothelin-1, asymmetrical dimethylarginine, tumor necrosis factor-a, monocyte chemoattractant protein-1, soluble vascular cell adhesion molecule, high-sensitivity C-reactive protein, and 8-isoprostane were measured. EECP increased brachial (+51% versus +2%) and femoral (+30% versus +3%) artery flow-mediated dilation, the nitric oxide turnover/production markers nitrate and nitrite (+36% versus +2%), and 6-keto-prostaglandin F1a (+71% versus +1%), whereas it decreased endothelin-1 (-25% versus +5%) and the nitric oxide synthase inhibitor asymmetrical dimethylarginine (-28% versus +0.2%) in treatment versus sham groups, respectively (all P<0.05). EECP decreased the proinflammatory cytokines tumor necrosis factor-a (-16% versus +12%), monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (-13% versus +0.2%), soluble vascular cell adhesion molecule-1 (-6% versus +1%), high-sensitivity C-reactive protein (-32% versus +5%), and the lipid peroxidation marker 8-isoprostane (-21% versus +1.3%) in treatment versus sham groups, respectively (all P<0.05). EECP reduced angina classification (-62% versus 0%; P<0.001) in treatment versus sham groups, respectively. Conclusions-Our findings provide novel mechanistic evidence that EECP has a beneficial effect on peripheral artery flow-mediated dilation and endothelial-derived vasoactive agents in patients with symptomatic coronary artery disease.
- Brandjes DP, Buller HR, Heijboer H et
al.:Compression stockings reduced the occurrence of
post-thrombotic syndrome in proximal DVT. Lancet 349:759-62,
1977. Sized-to-fit, knee-length, graded compression stockings
significantly reduced the occurrence of mild-to-moderate and severe
post-thrombotic syndrome in patients with a first episode of
proximal deep vein thrombosis. All patients had initially been
treated with heparin for 5 or more days and then were given
warfarin for three months. Comments: Prandroni et al (Ann Intern
Med 125:1-7, 1996) remind us that 29% of patients with DVT develop
the post-thrombotic syndrome within 8 years. Compression stockings
are helpful but care must be exercised in not applying them to DVT
patients with concomitant ischemia.
- Cheng JM, Valk SD et al: Usefulness of intra-aortic balloon pump counterpulsation in patients with cardiogenic shock from acute myocardial infarction. Am J Cardiol 104:327-32, 2009. Although intra-aortic balloon pump (IABP) counterpulsation is increasingly being used for the treatment of patients with cardiogenic shock from acute myocardial infarction, data on the long-term outcomes are lacking. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the 30-day and long-term mortality and to identify predictors for 30-day and long-term all-cause mortality of patients with acute myocardial infarction complicated by cardiogenic shock who were treated with IABP. From January 1990 to June 2004, 300 consecutive patients treated with IABP were included. The mean age of the study population was 61 +/- 11 years, and 79% of the patients were men. The survival rate until IABP removal after successful hemodynamic stabilization was 70% (n = 211). The overall cumulative 30-day survival rate was 58%. The 30-day mortality rate decreased over time from 52% in 1990 to 1994 to 36% in 2000 to 2004 (p for trend <0.05). Follow-up ranged from 0 to 15 years. In patients who survived until IABP removal, the cumulative 1-, 5-, and 10-year survival rate was 69%, 58%, and 36%, respectively. The adjusted predictors of long-term mortality were arrhythmias during the intensive cardiac care unit stay (hazard ratio [HR] 1.8, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.2 to 2.9) and renal failure during the intensive cardiac care unit stay (HR 2.5, 95% CI 1.3 to 5.1). After adjustment, treatment with primary percutaneous coronary intervention (HR 0.5, 95% CI 0.3 to 0.9) and coronary artery bypass grafting (HR 0.4, 95% CI 0.2 to 0.8) were associated with lower long-term mortality. In conclusion, in patients with acute myocardial infarction complicated by cardiogenic shock treated with IABP, the 30-day survival improved with time and an encouraging number of patients survived in the long term. Comments: The balloon requires a skillful physician to insert it. It blocks flow to the distal aorta. It is associated with complications at its insertion site and occasionally causes cholesterol emboli (for more on its complications, see http://www.circulatorboot.com/Newsletter/vol2numb3.html). The Circulator Boot enjoys freedom from these problems. In this article we see the prognosis of balloon patients treated for vascular shock remains guarded.
- Cheung AT, Savino JS, Weiss SJ:Beat-to-beat
augmentation of left ventricular function by intraaortic
counterpulsation. Anesthesiology 1996 Mar;84(3):545-54.
Author's Abstract: BACKGROUND: Measuring the effects of intraaortic
balloon counterpulsation (IABP) in single cardiac beats may permit
an improved understanding of the physiologic mechanisms by which
IABP improves the circulation. The objective of the study was to
use trans- esophageal echocardiography in combination with
hemodynamic measurements to test the hypothesis that IABP improves
global left ventricular systolic function selectively in the
IABP-augmented cardiac beats by acutely decreasing left ventricular
afterload. METHODS: Twenty-seven studies in which the IABP-to-R
wave trigger ratio was serially changed from 1:1, 1:2, 1:4, 0:1
(IABP off) and back to 1:1 were performed in 20 anesthetized
cardiac surgical patients during IABP support. Left ventricular
short-axis end-diastolic cross-sectional area, end-systolic area,
mean end-systolic wall thickness, and ejection time were measured
by transesophageal echocardiography at the midpapillary muscle
level. Aortic pressure was measured simultaneously from the central
lumen of the intraaortic balloon catheter. These measurements were
used to calculate the fractional area change, end-systolic
meridional wall stress, and heart rate-corrected velocity of
circumferential fiber shortening. The echocardiographic and
hemodynamic parameters of left ventricular preload, afterload, and
systolic function immediately after balloon deflation
(IABP-augmented cardiac beats) were compared to the parameters
measured during nonaugmented cardiac beats to determine the
beat-to-beat effects of IABP on left ventricular function. RESULTS:
IABP-augmented cardiac beats had a decreased systolic arterial
pressure and end-systolic meridional wall stress and increased
diastolic blood pressure, fractional area change, and velocity of
circumferential fiber shortening compared to nonaugmented cardiac
beats. IABP did not cause significant beat-to-beat changes in heart
rate, pulmonary artery diastolic pressure, or central venous
pressure. The improvement in left ventricular systolic function
associated with IABP-augmented cardiac beats correlated with the
decrease in end-systolic meridional wall stress for that cardiac
beat. CONCLUSIONS: Beat-to-beat echocardiographic and hemodynamic
measurements performed in anesthetized cardiac surgical patients
during IABP support demonstrated improved left ventricular systolic
function and decreased left ventricular systolic wall stress in the
cardiac beats immediately after balloon deflation. The relationship
between left ventricular systolic function and left ventricular
systolic wall stress during IABP support suggests that afterload
reduction was an important mechanism by which IABP instantaneously
improved circulatory function in anesthetized cardiac surgical
patients. Comments: And these effects are found with the
decompression of a small intraaortic balloon. See Dillon 1998 below
for similar large effects seen with the decompression of the
Circulator Boot.
- Chleboun GS, Howell JN, Baker HL, Ballard TN, Graham JL,
Hallman HL, Perkins LE, Schauss JH and Conatser RR:
Intermittent pneumatic compression effect on eccentric
exercise-induced swelling, stiffness, and strength loss.
Arch Phys Med Rehabil 76:744-749, 1995. Authors conclude that
therapy is effective in temporarily decreasing the swelling and
stiffness after exercise-induced muscle injury.
- Delis KT, Nicolaides AN, Wolfe JH, Stansby G:
Improving walking ability and ankle brachial pressure indices in
symptomatic peripheral vascular disease with intermittent pneumatic
foot compression: a prospective controlled study with one-year
follow-up. J Vasc Surg 31:650-61, 2000. Abstract: PURPOSE: Intermittent pneumatic foot compression (IPC(foot)) augments arterial leg inflow. It has been suggested that prolonged use of impulse leg compression at home might ameliorate claudication caused by peripheral vascular disease by improving collateral circulation. The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of IPC(foot) treatment on claudication distance and arterial hemodynamics in patients with intermittent claudication caused by peripheral vascular disease. METHODS: Thirty-seven patients with stable intermittent claudication were admitted to this prospective controlled study. Of these, 25 patients received IPC(foot) (>4 hr/d) for 4.5 months (group 1), and the other 12 patients acted as control patients (group 2). Both groups were advised to exercise unsupervised for a minimum of 1 hour daily and received aspirin (75 mg/d). Groups were matched for age, sex, risk factors, claudication distances, and ankle pressures at baseline. In each patient, initial claudication distance (ICD), absolute claudication distance (ACD), resting ankle brachial index (r-ABI), ankle brachial pressure index after exercise (p-eABI), and popliteal artery volume flow were measured at day 0, 2 weeks, and 1, 2, 3, and 4.5 months. On completion of the treatment period (4.5 months), both groups continued with aspirin (75 mg/d) and unsupervised exercise and were re-examined after 12 months. Data analysis is based on nonparametric statistics, the Wilcoxon signed ranks test, and the Mann-Whitney test for intragroup and intergroup comparisons, respectively. Results are expressed as median and interquartile ranges. RESULTS: Over the 4.5 months of active treatment, (1) median ICD in group 1 increased by 146% (P <.001), from 78 m (interquartile range, 65-102 m) at baseline to 191.5 m (interquartile range, 127-254 m); ICD did not significantly increase in group 2; (2) median ACD in group 1 improved by 106% (P <.001), from 124 m (interquartile range, 100-160 m) to 255 m (interquartile range, 149-398 m); no significant changes were documented in group 2; (3) median r-ABI in group 1 rose by 18% (P <.001), from 0.57 (interquartile range, 0.48-0.62) to 0.67 (interquartile range, 0.64-0.70); no improvement was noted in group 2; (4) median p-eABI in group 1 rose by 110% (P <.001), from 0.21 (interquartile range, 0.07-0.27) to 0.44 (interquartile range, 0. 36-0.52); no changes were noted in group 2; and (5) median popliteal artery volume flow in group 1 improved by 36% (P <.001), from 100 mL/min (interquartile range, 59-163 mL/min) to 136 mL/min (interquartile range, 99.5-173.4 mL/min); no significant changes were found in group 2. At 4.5 months, ICD, ACD, r-ABI, and p-eABI in group 1 were all significantly better than those in group 2 (P <.01). Twelve months' posttreatment, walking ability and ABIs in group 1 were not statistically different from those at 4.5 months and remained significantly better than those of control subjects. CONCLUSION: Intermittent pneumatic foot compression used at home for 4.5 months increases claudication distance by over 100%. Associated increases in r-ABI by 18%, p-eABI by 110%, and arterial calf inflow by 36% suggest an improved collateral circulation. Maximum benefit seems to be offered over the initial 3 months. Treatment benefits are maintained 1 year after treatment. A multicenter study is indicated to quantify actual benefits and to demonstrate cost effectiveness.
- Delis KT, Nicolaides AN, Labropoulos N, Stansby G:
The acute effects of intermittent pneumatic foot versus calf
versus simultaneous foot and calf compression on popliteal artery
hemodynamics: a comparative study. J Vasc Surg 32:284-92,
2000.Irvine Laboratory for Cardiovascular Investigation and
Research, Imperial College School of Medicine, Academic Vascular
Surgery, St Mary's Hospital, Paddington, United
Kingdom.INTRODUCTION: Intermittent pneumatic compression (IPC) is
currently being investigated with respect to its effect on distal
arterial volume flow in patients with peripheral vascular disease.
Recently published data have shown a substantial acute enhancement
in arterial calf inflow in response to IPC of the lower limb in
both intermittent claudication and leg ischemia. PURPOSE: The aim
of the study was to compare the immediate effects of intermittent
pneumatic foot (IPC(foot)) versus calf (IPC(calf)) versus
simultaneous foot and calf compression (IPC(foot+calf)) on
popliteal artery hemodynamics in patients with intermittent
claudication (Fontaine II) and in normal subjects, using duplex
ultrasonography. For this purpose, 25 limbs of 20 healthy subjects
(age range [mean], 51-74 [64] years) and 31 limbs of 25 claudicants
(age range [mean], 56-81 [66.5] years; resting ankle-brachial
indices, 0.38-0.75 [0.55]) were examined in the sitting position
with and without IPC compression. RESULTS: Mean popliteal artery
flow in healthy subjects increased by 98.8% on application of
IPC(foot), 188% with IPC(calf), and 274% with IPC(foot+calf) (all P
<.001). Mean flow in claudicants increased by 58% on application
of IPC(foot), 132% with IPC(calf), and 174% with IPC(foot+calf)
(all P ><.001). The mean velocity, peak systolic velocity,
and end diastolic velocity displayed a pattern of change similar to
that for volume flow in both groups. Pulsatility index decreased in
both groups on application of IPC; the lowest values were generated
with IPC(foot+calf). CONCLUSION: Of the three compression modes
investigated, IPC(foot+calf) was the most effective means of
acutely augmenting arterial calf inflow in arteriopaths and
normals. The significant increase in end diastolic velocity and
decrease in pulsatility index indicate that peripheral
vasodilatation is the central mechanism in this impulse-related
flow augmentation. Prospective trials are indicated to determine
the clinical potential of the long-term effects of IPC(foot+calf)
in patients with symptomatic peripheral vascular
disease.Comments: Porter accompanied the first article (that
above this one) with an editorial suggesting these authors were
finally showing boots worked. In that article, they merely pumped
on the foot. Here they are showing significantly more effect if
they pumped on the foot and calf. If they increased their pumping
rate and applied pressure in end-diastole, they would then have our
Mini-Boot.
- Delis KT, Knaggs AL: Duration and amplitude decay of acute arterial leg inflow enhancement with intermittent pneumatic leg compression: an insight into the implicated physiologic mechanisms. J Vasc Surg 42(4): 717-25, 2005. PURPOSE: By acutely enhancing the arterial leg inflow, intermittent pneumatic leg compression (IPC) improves the walking ability, arterial hemodynamics, and quality of life of claudicants. We quantified the duration of acute leg inflow enhancement with IPC of the foot (IPC(foot)), calf (IPC(calf)), or both (IPC(foot+calf)) and its amplitude decay in claudicants and controls in relation to the pulsatility index, an estimate of peripheral resistance. These findings are cross-correlated with the features of the three implicated physiologic mechanisms: (1) an increase in the arteriovenous pressure gradient, (2) suspension of peripheral sympathetic autoregulation, and (3) enhanced release of nitric oxide with flow and shear-stress increase. METHODS: Twenty-six limbs of 24 claudicants with superficial femoral artery occlusion or stenoses (>75%) and 24 limbs of 20 healthy controls matched for age and sex, meeting stringent selection criteria, had their popliteal volume flow and pulsating index (peak-to-peak velocity/mean velocity) measured with duplex scanning at rest and upon delivery of IPC. Spectral waveforms were analyzed for 50 seconds after IPC delivery per 5-second segments. The three IPC modes were applied in a true crossover design. Data analysis was performed with the Page, Friedman, Wilcoxon, Mann-Whitney and chi2 tests. RESULTS: The median duration of flow enhancement in claudicants exceeded 50 seconds with IPC(foot), IPC(calf), and IPC(foot+calf) but was shorter (P < .001) in the controls (32.5 to 40 seconds). Among the three IPC modes, the duration of flow enhancement differed (P < .05) only between IPC(foot) and IPC(foot+calf). After reaching its peak within 5 seconds of IPC, flow enhancement decayed at rates decreasing over time (trend, P < .05, Page test), which in both groups were highest at 5 to 20 seconds, moderate at 20 to 35 seconds, and lowest at 35 to 50 seconds (P < .05, Friedman test). Baseline and peak flow with all IPC modes was similar between the two groups. Pulsatility index attenuation in claudicating limbs lasted a median 32.5 seconds with IPC(foot), 37.5 seconds with IPC(calf), and 40 seconds with IPC(foot+calf); duration of pulsatility index attenuation was shorter in the control limbs with IPC(foot) (30 seconds), IPC(calf) (32.5 seconds), or IPC(foot+calf) (35 seconds), yet differences, as well as those among the 3 IPC modes, were not significant. CONCLUSION: Leg inflow enhancement with IPC exceeds 50 seconds in claudicants and lasts 32.5 to 40 seconds in the controls. Peak flow occurs concurrently with maximal pulsatility index attenuation, within 5 seconds of IPC. Irrespective of group or IPC mode, the decay rate (%) of flow enhancement is highest within 5 to 20 seconds of IPC, moderate at 20 to 35 seconds, and lowest at 35 to 50 seconds. Since attenuation in peripheral resistance terminates with the mid time period (20 to 35 seconds) of flow decay, and nitric oxide has a half-life of <7 to 10 seconds, the study's data indicate that all implicated physiologic mechanisms (1, 2, and 3) are likely active immediately after IPC delivery (0 to 20 sec) and all but nitric oxide are effective in the mid time period (20 to 35 seconds). As the pulsatility index has returned to baseline, the late phase of flow enhancement (35 to 50 seconds) could be attributable to the declining arteriovenous pressure gradient alone. Comments: This study is included among our boot articles although the apparatus used is not a boot that covers and treats large portions of the leg but a cuff that compresses the calf and/or foot in pulses considerably slower than the Circulator Boot. Here again we see transient improvements in blood flow versus the long-lasting effects of Circulator Boot therapy.
- Delis KT, Nicolaides AN: Effect of Intermittent Pneumatic Compression of Foot and Calf on Walking Distance, Hemodynamics, and Quality of Life in Patients With Arterial Claudication. A Prospective Randomized Controlled Study With 1-Year Follow-up. Ann Surg 241: 431-441, 2005. Abstract: Summary Background Data: Perioperative mortality, graft failure, and angioplasty limitations militate against active intervention for claudication. With the exception of exercise programs, conservative treatments yield modest results. Intermittent pneumatic compression [IPC] of the foot used daily for 3 months enhances the walking ability and pressure indices of claudicants. Although IPC applied to the foot and calf together [IPCfoot+calf] is hemodynamically superior to IPC of the foot, its clinical effects in claudicants remain undetermined. Objective: This prospective randomized controlled study evaluates the effects of IPCfoot+calf on the walking ability, peripheral hemodynamics, and quality of life [QOL] in patients with arterial claudication. Methods: Forty-one stable claudicants, meeting stringent inclusion and exclusion criteria, were randomized to receive either IPCfoot+calf and aspirin[75 mg] (Group 1; n = 20), or aspirin[75 mg] alone (Group 2; n = 21), with stratification for diabetes and smoking. Groups matched for age, sex, initial [ICD] and absolute [ACD] claudication distances, pressure indices [ABI], popliteal artery flow, and QOL with the short-form 36 Health Survey Questionnaire (SF-36). IPCfoot+calf (120 mm Hg, inflation 4 seconds × 3 impulses per minute, calf inflate delay 1 second) was used for 5 months, =2.5 hours daily. Both groups were advised to exercise unsupervised. Evaluation of patients, after randomization, included the ICD and ACD, ABI, popliteal artery flow with duplex and QOL* at baseline*, 1/12, 2/12, 3/12, 4/12, 5/12* and 17/12. Logbooks allowed compliance control. Wilcoxon and Mann-Whitney corrected[Bonferroni] tests were used. Results: At 5/12 median ICD, ACD, resting and postexercise ABI had increased by 197%, 212%, 17%, and 64%, respectively, in Group 1 (P < 0.001), but had changed little (P > 0.1) in Group 2; Group 1 had better ICD, ACD, and resting and postexercise ABI (P < 0.01) than Group 2. Inter- and intragroup popliteal flow differences at 5/12 were small (P > 0.1). QOL had improved significantly in Group 1 but not in Group 2; QOL in the former was better (P < 0.01) than in Group 2. QOL in Group 1 was better (P < 0.01) than in Group 2 at 5/12. IPC was complication free. IPC compliance (=2.5 hours/d) was >82% at 1 month and >85% at 3 and 5 months. ABI and walking benefits in Group 1 were maintained a year after cessation of IPC treatment. Conclusions: IPCfoot+calf emerged as an effective, high-compliance, complication-free method for improving the walking ability and pressure indices in stable claudication, with a durable outcome. These changes were associated with a significant improvement in all aspects of QOL evaluated with the SF-36. Despite some limited benefit noted in some individuals, unsupervised exercise had a nonsignificant impact overall.
- de Simone G, di Lorenzo L, Ferrara LA, Costantino G, Fasano
ML, Soro S, Mancini M: Noninvasive assessment of
hemodynamic changes during therapy with nitrendipine in arterial
hypertension. Jpn Heart J 28:73-84, 1987. Author's abstract:
Changes in hemodynamic variables regulating systolic function were
examined by M-mode echocardiography in 14 patients with
long-duration primary uncomplicated hypertension treated with
nitrendipine once daily (20 mg). At the end of treatment (8th week)
blood pressure and peripheral resistance were greatly reduced (p
less than 0.0001), while the indices of cardiac function (ejection
fraction and cardiac index) showed significant increases (p less
than 0.01). The variations in ejection fraction were analyzed by
multiple linear regression and were mainly influenced by the
decrease in end-systolic stress (contribution: 60%). At baseline,
despite no radiographic or clinical signs of heart failure, 6 of
the studied patients showed impaired systolic function, likely due
to the strength of other variables (age, risk factors); in those
patients, systolic function was clearly enhanced at the end of
treatment, while no change was found in patients with initial
normal pump function. Changes in cardiac output were due to a
significant increase in heart rate in patients with normal pump
function and to improved stroke volume in the others. Left
ventricular mass index was slightly reduced (p less than 0.005),
primarily because of the reduction in end-diastolic volume (p less
than 0.01). When analyzed by the 2 subgroups (with or without
impaired systolic function), the left ventricular mass index
appeared to be significantly reduced only in those patients with
normal basal pump function. This difference was most likely due to
the different effects of treatment on end-diastolic
volume.Comments: This article is included because, like the
article below (Dillon 1998) describing the hemodynamic effects of
booting, the importance of diastolic unloading is
emphasized.
- Dick P, Mlekusch W et al: Decreasing incidence of critical limb ischemia after intra-aortic balloon pump counterpulsation. Angiology 60(2):235-41, 2009. The authors investigated the incidence of critical limb ischemia (CLI) in 187 patients with intra-aortic balloon pump (IABP) support during a 6-year study period and determined risk factors and long-term outcome (median 5 years) after discharge from a cardiac intensive care unit. Cardiogenic shock following acute myocardial infarction was the predominant cause of IABP support. CLI occurred in 10% of the patients after IABP implantation. Nevertheless, in light of the overall high mortality in this patient population, CLI seems not a primary concern. Furthermore, its incidence significantly decreased during recent years. Duration of IABP support was a significant predictor for CLI.Comments: No such problems with the Circulator Boot.
- Dillon RS: An end-diastolic air compression boot
for circulation augmentation. J Clin Engineering 3:63, 1980.
Description of Circulator Boot systems and comparison with other
vascular pneumatic boots.
- Dillon RS: Effect of therapy with pneumatic
end-diastolic leg compression boot on peripheral vascular tests and
on the clinical course of peripheral vascular disease.
Angiology 31:614-638, 1980. The Circulator Boot is a new
end-diastolic pneumatic leg compression device. This report
describes its effect on 6 normal young people, 8 ambulatory
patients with mild peripheral arterial disease, and 21 consecutive
patients (of whom 18 were hospitalized) with severe peripheral
arterial disease in 25 legs. The courses of 4 patients are
discussed in detail. Significant beneficial effects were documented
by subcutaneous PO2 levels, pulse volume measurements, ankle blood
pressure measurements, and Doppler ultrasound tracings. Twenty-two
of the 25 severe legs benefited clinically from therapy. Immediate
therapeutic effects from the boot are attributed to decreases in
venous pressure, interstitial fluid pressure, vasoconstriction, and
viscosity, and to increases in cardiac output, pulse pressure, and
fibrinolysis in the treated leg. The long-term beneficial effects
of boot therapy may be related to improved collateral flow and to
the rechanneling of obstructed vessels. Comments: The baseline ABI was under 0.5 in the dorsalis pedis in 17 legs and in the posterior tibial in 15 legs. Significant
improvements were seen in all of the noninvasive vascular tests
measured:
Table 1: Summary of Vascular Tests
Means +/- Standard Deviations
Increases in BP mm Hg Dorsalis Pedis 43.1+/-11.2 P<0.001 Post. Tibial 32.1+/-11.1 P<0.01 Increases in ABI Dorsalis Pedis 31.0+/-8.4 P<0.01 Post. Tibial 23.7+/-8.4 P<0.02 Increases in Doppler Amplitudes Dorsalis Pedis 10.8+/-2.1 P<0.001 Post. Tibial 13.7+/-2.7 P<0.001 Increases in Ankle Oscillometry Indices 0.8+/-0.12 P<0.001) - - Number of Treatments 47.7+/-43.7 - Duration of Treatments 5.8+/-6.6weeks -
The patients were treated as long as needed to address successfully their clinical problems. The effects of a single treatment on the baseline PO2 levels were also reported; persentages of 26 (in relatively normal skin) to 1800% (in obviously ischemic skin) were seen. As serial angiograms posed significant risks to the patients, they were only done in occasional patients; some of these angiograms are shown in our case history section. The equipment and techniques have been subsequently improved. Osteomyelitis was not always easily cured with systemic antibiotics and boot alone. As noted below the addition of locally injected antibiotics proved beneficial (Dillon, 1986).
- Dillon RS: Treatment of resistant venous stasis
ulcers and dermatitis with the end-diastolic pneumatic compression
boot (TM). Angiology 37: 47-56, 1986. Abstract: The
end-diastolic pneumatic compression boot was used to treat 17
patients with difficult or refractory stasis dermatitis and ulcers.
Decreases in induration, pigmentation, and palpable thrombi were
observed and all patients were improved or healed. The boot
treatment allowed effective local administration of antibiotics on
gauze wrappings. Removal of the latter after treatments provided a
means of nonsurgical debridement. Healing was maintained by
periodic outpatient boot treatments in patients with close
follow-up. Ulcers recurred in patients lost to follow-up but again
responded to boot treatment. One diabetic man with knee
contractures and both severe venous and arterial disease relapsed
repetitively and lost both legs in spite of bilateral
femoral-popliteal bypasses and his boot treatments. Comments:
Venous stasis ulcers are really ischemic lesions in which the
blockage is on the venous side, rather than the arterial side.
Booting restores venous blood flow in promoting the dissolution of
the venous thrombi and in reducing induration and edema. Arterial
vascular tests significantly improved with the boot treatments in
the seven patients who had concomitant arterial disease. Pulmonary
emboli were not a problem. Care must be taken, however, in being
sure that new large clots are not present in the larger veins at
the start of therapy.
- Dillon RS: Successful treatment of osteomyelitis
and soft tissue infections in ischemic diabetic legs by antibiotic
injections and the end-diastolic pneumatic compression boot.
Ann Surg 204: 643-649, 1986. For abstract, see our library on
"Cellulitis, Osteomyelitis and Sepsis."
- Dillon RS: Treatment of osteomyelitis in diabetic
foot with systemic and locally-injected antibiotics and the
end-diastolic pneumatic compression boot - Case studies.
Vasc Surg (Westerminister Press) 24: 682-695, 1990. Abstract:The
treatment of 35 patients for 43 episodes of osteomyelitis in the
distal lower extremity is summarized and the long-term courses of
three patients are illustrated in detail. Systemic antibiotics were
used both to help control infection in the foot and to prevent
septic emboli. The systemic antibiotics were given by the oral
route alone (16 episodes), by the parenteral route alone (4
episodes), or by both oral and parenteral routes (22 episodes).
Local foot treatments included injections of antibiotics into the
infected areas of the foot, multielectrolyte-antibiotic foot soaks,
and the end-diastolic pneumatic compression boot. X-ray evidence of
osteomyelitis was found one to four weeks after it was clinically
suspected and was associated with an improvement in the clinical
status of the foot. Osteomyelitis was not considered an indication
for amputation. The osteomyelitis lesions healed and foot structure
and function were maintained. Comments: Lost in the editorial
process of this manuscript was the fact that these were not
selected for this report because of their successful treatment;
they were consecutive referrals who were found to have
osteomyelitis. Patients with severe ischemia and infection likely
present with gangrene. Patients with x-ray changes of osteomyelitis
must have sufficient blood flow to allow the serial dissolution and
remodeling processes characteristic of osteomyelitis. These
patients, hence, do have some blood flow and with the techniques
described may almost all be cured. It is to be appreciated, however, that most all these patients had significant ischemia: 26 feet had no palpable pulses, 4 had one palpable pulse while 12 feet had both the dorsalis pedis and posterior tibial palpable. The mean of the ABI in the dorsalis pedis and posterior tibial was under 0.6 in 13 feet and under 0.4 in 6 feet. Sterilization of the drainage,
healing of the associated ulcers and normalization of the sed rate
point to a success regardless what the x-ray may be showing.
Allowed some time (weeks to months), the involved bone may be
conserved without surgery. How do other centers fare with such cases? See Armstrong et al for the Texas Wound Classification System in our Epidemiology library; close to 100% of our patients would have had amputations in their institution. How is our success interpreted by some reviewers? Those in the Georgia Medicare system, for example, call us investigational, but they also ignore the success reported at the Mayo Clinic. View
original article in Vascular Surgery and/or
View 60 cases of osteomyelitis successfully treated by these techniques
- Dillon RS: Optimizing external cardiac-assist
compressions in patients with atrial fibrillation by anticipating
the next beat. Angiology 47: 123-129, 1996. Comments:
This is a computer analysis of the EKG strips taken from 30
patients with atrial fibrillation. An empirical formula was
developed and tested on the computer to significantly improve the
efficiency of the Circulator Boot in assisting the hearts of
patients with atrial fibrillation. This empirical formula has been
incorporated into the monitor of the Circulator Boot systems now in
production.
- Dillon RS: Fifteen years of experience in treating
2177 episodes of foot and leg lesions with the Circulator
Boot-Results of treatments with the Circulator
Boot.Angiology 48, Number 5, Part 2: S17-S34, 1997.
Abstract: Objective: To determine the clinical effectiveness
of the end-diastolic pneumatic compression boot and of local
antibiotics in treating limb lesions associated with diabetes and
peripheral arterial, venous and neuropathic disease. Research
Design and methods: Office and hospital data were kept over 15
years on 2177 episodes of leg problems classified by the Wagner
method for 1514 legs of 1035 patients largely referred because of
failure of standard therapies. The fate of the untreated legs
served as a control when possible. Results: Healing or
improvement of treated legs was seen above that in the literature
in all Wagner categories and was significant (P<0.001) compared
to the "control" leg which deteriorated in 38.7% of patients.
Significant risk factors against a successful outcome included
smoking, inability to walk, increased home distance from the boot
center, loss to treatment, hemodialysis, a Wagner 4-5
classification, inoperable iliac occlusions, vascular surgical
procedures before or after referral for boot therapy and an
aggressive vascular surgeon. Neuropathy allowed successful
treatment of lesions nondiabetic patients could not tolerate.
Relapse was significantly more frequent in ASO patients with
diabetes than without diabetes and in patients with neuropathy than
those with ASO. Diabetes did not affect the relapse rate in stasis
disease. The overall percentage of legs having major amputations
was low: 2.46% for diabetic legs at the initial treatment episode,
1.6% at the time of a relapse and 4.14% after seeking treatment
elsewhere. For nondiabetic patients, the respective risks were
similar: 2.0%, 1.18% and 2.88%. Comments: This study may be the
largest and the longest in the medical literature. It shows that
long lasting benefits may result from therapy with the Circulator
Boot systems. At medical meetings, our salesmen have been presented
with the criticism that the study is a one-man show and that it is
uncontrolled and retrospective in nature. In answer to these
criticisms, one might make many observations. An one-author study
is more likely to be uniform in technique (treatment technique is
described in the companion article). The study actually has
multiple controls: (a) the patients largely had had "control" or
standard therapies and were referred after they had failed; (b) the
fate of the good leg served as a control in many and it broke down
while the presenting diseased leg healed; (c) reviewers for the
insurance companies and Medicare could deny payments if the
therapies were not shown to be beneficial and necessary; and (c)the
referring physician frequently maintained surveillance of these
patients and could have discontinued the boot therapy if they saw
no progress. Finally, it should be appreciated that these
treatments were accomplished in real life situations: the community
hospital, the doctor's office and the nursing home... not in a
clinical research ward. The treatment works in real life.
Full text of this article
- Dillon RS: Patient assessment and examples of a
method of treatment-Use of the Circulator Boot in peripheral
vascular disease. Angiology 48, Number 5, part 2: S35-S58,
1997. Summary: Effective peripheral blood flow is positively
related to cardiac output and gravity (part dependent) and
inversely related to gravity (part elevated), venous pressure,
interstitial fluid pressure, degree of peripheral neuropathy,
arteriosclerotic and thrombotic arterial occlusions, and infection.
These factors are considered in the operation of the end-diastolic
pneumatic boot in the treatment of illustrative patients with
lymphedema, venous stasis disease, peripheral arteriosclerosis
obliterans, peripheral neuropathy, cellulitis and osteomyelitis and
the failing heart. A method of treatment that includes the use of
the boot and the injection of local antibiotics is described.Full
text of this article
- Dillon RS: Improved hemodynamics shown by
continuous monitoring of electrical impedance during external
counterpulsation with the end-diastolic pneumatic boot and improved
ambulatory EKG monitoring after 3 weeks of therapy.
Angiology 49: 523-535, 1998. Abstract: Six normal subjects and 12
patients with clinical angina and significant ST depressions during
baseline ambulatory cardiac monitoring were given a single
treatment with the end-diastolic pneumatic compression boot, the
Circulator Boot - TM. With the use of continuous electrical
impedance measurements, multiple hemodynamic variables were
followed in five situations: (1) baseline before pumping; during
end-diastolic pumping (2) on both legs after every heartbeat, (3)
on one leg after every heartbeat and (4) on both legs on alternate
beats; and (5) during pumping on both legs during every systole.
Both an increase in venous return and a reduction in afterload
likely contributed to significant increases in cardiac output
(51.1(33.6%), stroke volume (52.1(35.6%), dZ/dT (72.0(68.1%),
cardiac index (51.2(33.8%) and acceleration index (50.7(62.2%)
during end-diastolic pumping on both legs after every heartbeat. A
crucial role for afterload reduction was implicated by opposite
effects on CO, CI, dZ/dT and SV during systolic pumping. Again,
reductions (or lack of an increase) in ventricular ejection time
and/or the pre-ejection period suggested a decrease in afterload
during end-diastolic pumping. Pumping on one leg after every
heartbeat and on both legs on alternate heartbeats was also
effective but less so. After the initial study, the patients were
given 14 additional end-diastolic treatments to both legs over
three weeks. A clinical benefit was shown by symptomatic
improvement in all patients along with a significant reduction in
the amount and duration of the RST abnormalities in their
ambulatory heart monitoring (P=0.012). Comments: How does the
Circulator Boot work, we are commonly asked. Here we see that it is
a significant cardiac-assist device that improves stroke volume,
cardiac output and, presumably, coronary blood flow. Patients with
advanced heart failure commonly have cyanosis of their fingers and
toes which may disappear when heart function improves. In contrast
to the aortic balloon, the Circulator Boot does not need
specialized individuals to apply it; it may be promptly applied,
removed and applied again; it has no vascular complications; it
does not block blood flow to the lower body; it assists venous
return; it stimulates the elaboration of prostacyclin, nitric oxide
and fibrinolysins; and it has superior effects on systemic
hemodynamics. Indeed, the aortic balloon commonly changes
hemodynamic data little. Prolonged therapy with the Circulator
Boot, on the other hand, is more confining. The latter disadvantage
may be approached by alternating legs, sedating the patient and/or
removing the boot intermittently. It is interesting to consider the
physiology of the Circulator Boot historically and to contrast the
findings reported here with those of Frank in 1895 and Starling in
1914. Frank noted that an increase in preload increased the force
of contractions of the isolated frog heart. Starling utilized a
canine heart-lung preparation in which the lungs were artificially
ventilated (potentially preventing pulmonary congestion as right
atrial filling pressures were increased). While allowing aortic
pressure to increase about 5%, he found perhaps a 70% increase in
stroke volume after a 53% increase in right atrial filling pressure
and provided us with the now classic concept that cardiac output
increases to a point as the heart fibers are stretched with
increases in ventricular filling (Patterson SW, Piper H, Starling
EH: J Physiol 48:465, 1914). Again, he noted increases in stroke
volume, albeit less prominent, when ventricular volume was
increased by increasing peripheral vascular resistance and aortic
blood pressure. Two potentially detrimental effects of his
experiment are to be noted, however. First, ventricular dilatation
significantly increases the force each heart fiber must exert to
obtain a given intraventricular pressure; heart work increases and
heart efficiency decreases. Second, coronary artery perfusion
occurs predominantly in diastole and increased diastolic
ventricular pressures decrease coronary perfusion. While therapy
with the Circulator Boot does increase preload, the increase in
preload is shown not to be crucial. In contrast to Frank and
Starling, Circulator Boot therapy increases stroke volume by
decreasing afterload while at the same time decreasing heart work
and maintaining or ?increasing coronary perfusion. The clinical
implications of these observations are obvious. It is apparent, for
example, that the failing patient in intensive care may be better
served with Circulator Boot therapy than a fluid challenge.... and
that the benefit may be easily documented both rapidly and
non-invasively with an electrical impedance monitor
- Dillon RS: Pathophysiology of diabetic foot
lesions and their treatment with the Circulator Boot-TM.
Chapter 13 in "The Wound Management Manual" pages 141-211. Bok Y.
Lee editor. McGraw-Hill 2005.
- Erdling A, Bondesson S, Pettersson T, Edvinsson L.: Enhanced external counter pulsation in treatment of refractory angina pectoris: two year outcome and baseline factors associated with treatment failure. BMC Cardiovasc Disord 18;8:39, 2008. Abstract: BACKGROUND: Enhanced external counter pulsation (EECP) is a non-invasive treatment option for patients with refractory angina pectoris ineligible to further traditional treatment. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of EECP on patients at a Scandinavian medical centre and to investigate if outcome can be predicted by analysing baseline factors. METHODS: 86 consecutive patients (70 male, 16 female) were treated with EECP and followed for two years post treatment. Canadian cardiovascular society (CCS) class was analysed, and medication and adverse clinical events were researched prior to EECP, at the end of the treatment, and at six, 12 and 24 months thereafter. Patients responding to therapy by improving at least one CCS class were compared with those who failed to respond. Any differences in background factors were recorded and analysed. RESULTS: 79% of the patients responded to therapy by improving at least one CCS class. In general, the CCS class improved by one class after EECP treatment (3.05 before versus 2.14 after treatment). A total of 61.5% of the initial responders showed sustained improvement at the 12 month follow-up while 29% presented sustained improvement after 24 months. Treatment was most effective among patients suffering from CCS class III-IV angina pectoris, while patients suffering from CCS class II angina pectoris improved transiently but failed to show sustained improvement after the 12 month follow-up. Diabetes mellitus and calcium channel antagonists were more common among the non-responders (p < 0.05). CONCLUSION: This study confirms the safety and efficiency of EECP as a treatment option for patients suffering from refractory angina pectoris. The therapy is most beneficial in patients suffering from severe angina (CCS III-IV) while sustained response to therapy could not be verified among patients suffering from CCS class II angina pectoris.
- Eze AR, Comerota AJ, Cisek PL, Holland BS, Kerr RP,
Veeramasuneni R and Comerota Jr. A|J: Intermittent calf
and foot compression increases lower extremity blood flow.
Am J Surg 172:130-135, 1996. Authors' conclusions: Measured in the
sitting position, the resting popliteal artery blood flow and foot
skin perfusion are greater in patients with SFA occlusion compared
to normal volunteers. Following compression, popliteal artery blood
flow and skin perfusion increased in both groups, but relatively
more in volunteers. Increases in popliteal artery blood flow are
significantly higher with calf compression than with foot
compression for both groups. A patent SFA allows for additive
increases in popliteal artery blood flow with simultaneous foot and
calf compression in normal persons, whereas this is not observed in
patients. However, the increases in foot skin perfusion in patients
with an occluded SFA parallel the increases shown in normal
volunteers, with separate and simultaneous foot and calf
compression. Comments: Here a 22cm calf cuff and a 12cm foot
cuff were used to inflate to a pressure of 120 mm Hg over 0.3
seconds, hold the pressure 10 seconds and then release and remain
deflated for 20 seconds. The patients had ABI's in the supine
position of 0.55 to 0.75. Hypothesizing a brachial artery pressure
of 140 mm Hg, their ankle blood pressures might have varied from 77
to 105 mm Hg. In the sitting position with a vertical calf, the
ankle is perhaps 36 inches below the aortic root or 30 inches below
it when the foot is on a "low stool" (the top of the calf cuff, of
course, is closer to the heart and is less benefited by the
following calculations). As 30 inches of water pressure equals 55
mm Hg pressure, the perfusion pressure at the ankle was the sum of
the two or 77+55 to 105+55 mm Hg. Thus, 132 to 160 mmHg pressure
was opposed by the 120 mm pressure of the inflated cuffs in their
study. For most patients in their study, the cuff pressure was not
sufficient to either obstruct or reverse arterial inflow; as shown
below, the same may not be true for patients with more severe
ischemia. Here, the pressure was clearly sufficient to expel a
considerable volume of venous blood and, on release of the cuffs,
markedly increase the distal arterial/venous gradient.
The data below shows what happens, however, when a leg is very ischemic and has a progressive drop in systolic pressure from the groin to the foot, a boot encompassing the leg from the groin to the ankle is used, and the boot is inflated to 55 mm Hg for periods of several seconds. These tracings were obtained from a patient referred to the Bryn Mawr Circulator Boot Clinic after his leg had deteriorated elsewhere after treatments with a boot designed for treating lymphedema and venous stasis. In obtaining this study, a Circulator Boot was utilized setting the delay time to zero and the compression time to one second; in effect the boot continued to compress the leg until the boot switch was manually turned off. The boot, hence, could be alternately inflated and deflated for any desired time period. The graph reads from right to left. A baseline period is followed by a series of compressions and decompressions lasting several seconds each. The subcutaneous PO2 level is seen to progressively drop. The boot was then set to deliver end-diastolic compressions and the PO2 tension is seen to progressively rise. Such measurements are not necessary in clinical practice as improper pumping will produce pain and numbness in the distal extremity. If such pain occurs with end-diastolic pumping, the Circulator Boot is set to allow more arterial inflow by decreasing the compression rate from 1:1 to 1:2 or 1:3.

Subcutaneous PO2 Changes in an Ischemic Leg as Influenced by End-diastolc Compressions versus Compressions Lasting a Few Seconds - Filip, John: APWCA Case Study #2: Application of end-diastolic pneumatic compression therapy with the Circulator Boot. Podiatry Management 26(9): 149-159, 2007. No abstract available. Illustrated case report in which lady with advanced lesions of both legs and feet spared bilateral amputations.
- Filip JR, Dillon RS: Treatment of end-stage "trash feet" with the end-diastolic pneumatic boot. Angiology 59(2):214-9, 2008. This study reassessed the clinical effect of Circulator Boot (CB) therapy in patients with cholesterol embolization syndrome (CES) of the lower extremities. The medical records were reviewed of 27 patients consecutively referred to the Bryn Mawr Wound Care and Vascular Center with CES who had not responded to previous therapies. All patients with CES referred from January 1, 1997, to September 19, 2005, were followed up and included in the study. The alternate therapy offered for most patients at the time of referral was limb amputation. The median age of the patients was 65 years (age range, 46-84 years) at the time of diagnosis. Healing of CES was observed after a median interval of 11 months (range, 3-32 months) following the initiation of CB therapy. The total number of legs treated was 41. Of 41 legs, 33 (81%) were totally healed, 6 (15%) improved, and 2 (5%) were amputated. After an initial period of improvement, one patient died a month later of causes unrelated to CES or CB therapy. Another patient improved and discontinued treatment before he was totally healed. Cholesterol embolization syndrome is seen predominantly in patients following cardiac or vascular procedures but may occur spontaneously. The CB seems to be the only effective noninvasive therapy for CES. Early initiation of therapy is essential to minimize tissue loss and patient discomfort.
- Fisher CG, Blachut Pa, Salvian AJ, Meek RN and O'Brien
PJ: Effectiveness of pneumatic compression devices for
the prevention of thromboembolic disease in orthopaedic truama
patients: a prospective randomized study of compression alone
versus no prophylaxis. J Ortho Trauma 9:1-7, 1995.
Sequential leg sleeves cycling at 71 second intervals with each
compression lasting 11 seconds...ankle 45mm Hgk, calf 35-40mm Hg,
and thigh 25mm Hg. Among patients with hip fractures, TE events
occurred in 12% of controls and in 4% of treated patients (P <
0.02). No significant difference in pelvic fracture patients.
- Gilbart MK, Oglivie-Harris DJ, Broadhurst C and Clarfield
M: Anterior tibial compartment pressures during
intermittent sequential pneumatic compression therapy.Am J
Sports Med 23:769-772, 1995. Abstract: We studied the anterior
tibial compartment pressures during the application of a JOBST
sequential intermittent pneumatic compression device on 5 healthy
human volunteers (10 legs). Intracompartmental pressures were
measured using a slit catheter. The measurements of interstitial
pressures were increased for approximately 120 seconds during each
cycle. Pressure measurements in the inflated pressure sleeve varied
less than 10% with the measured anterior compartment pressures
during intermittent pneumatic compression therapy. This
intermittent pneumatic pressure device may elevate intramuscular
pressure significantly above that necessary to render muscle
ischemic. However, these periods of pressure elevation are not long
enough to produce any significant adverse effects, and the
beneficial effects of decreased edema fluid may be safely
realized.
- Ginsberg JS, Brill-Edwards P, Kowalchuk G, Hirsh J:
Intermittent compression units for the postphlebitic
syndrome. A pilot study. Arch Intern Med 149: 1651-2, 1989.
The postphlebitic syndrome is a common affliction with limited
therapeutic options. Patients who fail to respond to treatment with
graded elastic compression stockings often develop a chronic pain
syndrome manifested by intractable pain and swelling. Because
lymphedema, a condition also associated with leg pain and swelling,
has been successfully treated by intermittent compressive therapy
with an extremity pump, we conducted a pilot study of compressive
therapy in patients with severe postphlebitic syndrome. All five
patients studied had dramatic improvement in symptoms and
functional status without side effects. Although a large randomized
trial is needed to properly evaluate compressive therapy, it
appears to be very effective in selected patients.
- Goldman BS, Hill TJ, Rosenthal GA, Scully HE, Weisel RD and
Baird RJ: Complications associated with use of the
intra-aortic balloon pump. Can J Surg 25:153-156, 1982. 299
patients between 1977 and 1979. Overall complication rate of 24.4%
. Patients with inoperable ASHD or severe left ventricular
dysfunction especially at risk (complications in 47.6%). Vascular
complications: aortic dissection 1.3%, perforation 0.3%, bleeding
at site 2.3%, femoral or iliac occlusion 1%, thromboembolism 4.3%
and limb ischemia 5.4%. Infections developed at the femoral site in
5.7% and systemic infection developed in 2.3%.
- Gruenes J, Nelson JP et al: An evaluation of the efficacy of the Circulator Boot in altering hemodynamics of the ischemic lower extremity and foot. Midwest Podiatry Conference 2005 (Chicago). Barry University School of Grad Med Sci. Every pumped extremity had increased perfusion after four weeks with an average increase of 43%. Twelve of 13 long term ulcers healed during the study.
- Han JH, Leung TW, Lam WW et al:: Preliminary Findings of External Counterpulsation for Ischemic Stroke Patient With Large Artery Occlusive Disease. Stroke 39:1340-3, 2008.
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: We aimed to investigate the feasibility and therapeutic effect of external counterpulsation (ECP) in ischemic stroke. METHODS: The trial was a randomized, crossover, assessment-blinded, proof-of-concept trial. ECP treatment consisted of 35 daily 1-hour sessions. Patients were randomized to either early (ECP weeks 1 to 7 and no ECP weeks 8 to 14) or late group (no ECP weeks 1 to 7 and ECP weeks 8 to 14). Primary outcomes were an overall change in National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS) and cerebral blood flow estimated by color velocity imaging quantification. Secondary outcomes were change in NIHSS, color velocity imaging quantification, favorable functional outcome (modified Rankin scale, 0 to 2), and stroke recurrence at weeks 7 and 14, respectively. RESULTS: Fifty patients were recruited. At week 7, there was a significant change in NIHSS (early 3.5 vs late 1.9; P=0.042). After adjusting for treatment sequence, ECP was associated with a favorable trend of change in NIHSS of 2.1 vs 1.3 for non-ECP (P=0.061). Changes of color velocity imaging quantification were not significant but tended to increase with ECP. At week 14, a favorable functional outcome was found in 100% of early group patients compared to 76% in the late group (P=0.022). CONCLUSIONS: ECP is feasible for ischemic stroke patients with larger artery disease.
- Henry WL, Morganroth J et al: Relation between echocardiographically determined left atrial size and atrial fibrillation.Circulation 53:273-279, 1976.
In an attempt to define quantitatively the relation between left atrial size and atrial fibrillation, echocardiography was used to study 85 patients with isolated mitral valve disease, 50 patients with isolated aortic valve disease, and 130 patients with asymmetric septal hypertrophy. In all three groups of patients, atrial fibrillation was rare when left atrial dimension was below 44 mm (3 of 117 or 3%) but common when this dimension exceeded 40 mm (80 of 148 or 54%). In addition, when left atrial dimension exceeds 45 mm, cardioversion, while initially successful, is unlikely to produce sinus rhythm that can be maintained at least six months. These data suggest that left atrial size is an important factor in the development of atrial fibrillation and in determining the long term result of cardioversion. The pathophysiologic mechansim most consistent with this is that a chronic hemodynamic burden initially produces left atrial enlargement which in turn predisposes to atrial fibrillation. Only prospective studies will determine definitively whether these observations will be useful in decisions concerning prophylactic anticoagulation and elective cardioversion. Comments: Left atrial size plays a role likely in the initiation and reoccurrence of atrial fibrillation. It is possible that the conversion of some of our boot patients with recent onset atrial fibrillation to normal sinus rhythm is due to the marked reduction in afterload associated with boot therapy allowing the left ventricle to empty more readily and decreasing any back
flow into the left atrium.... atrial size may be reduced.
- Henein MY, Das SK, O'Sullivan C, Kakkar VV, Gillbe CE,
Gibson DG: Effect of acute alterations in afterload on
left ventricular function in patients with combined coronary artery
and peripheral vascular disease. Heart 75(2): 151-8, 1966.
Abstract: Objective: To assess the effect of acute alterations in
afterload by aortoiliac clamping, during peripheral vascular
surgery, on left ventricular function. Design: Prospective
examination of the left ventricular long axis and transmitral
Doppler flow preoperatively and intraoperatively; before aortic
clamping, during clamping and 5 min, 15 min, and 5 days after
unclamping. Setting: A tertiary referral centre for cardiac and
vascular disease equipped with invasive and non-invasive
facilities. Patients: 20 patients (11 men; mean (SD) age 61 (8)
years) with significant aortoiliac disease and documented coronary
artery disease and 21 normal controls of similar age. Results:
Preoperatively: long axis function was abnormal compared with that
in normal controls. In systole total long axis excursion and peak
shortening rate were reduced, onset of shortening delayed, and
there was pre-ejection lengthening (P<0.001). In diastole there
was abnormal shortening during isovolumic relaxation, delaying the
onset of long axis lengthening (P><0.001). Peak lengthening
rate was also reduced and A wave excursion increased
(P><0.001). Transmitral Doppler showed increased A wave
velocity and reduced E/A diastolic flow velocities ratio
(P><0.001). Intraoperatively: preclamping results did not
differ from those before operation. With clamping the extent of
systolic and diastolic abnormalities promptly increased as to a
lesser extent did those of transmitral flow velocity, although
heart rate and blood pressure did not change significantly. Total
long axis excursion and A wave amplitude were more reduced by
aortic than iliac clamping, whereas the onset of lengthening was
more delayed and the lengthening velocity more reduced with iliac
clamping. Some 5 min after unclamping systolic long axis function
had already returned towards normal; total excursion increased, as
did peak shortening rate, and the onset of shortening became less
delayed (P><0.001). In diastole the delayed onset of
lengthening regressed, its lengthening velocity increased, and A
wave excursion fell (P><0.001). Early diastolic transmitral
flow velocity also increased. This improvement in systolic and
diastolic long axis function had progressed 15 min after unclamping
but showed no further change at 5 days. At 5 days after operation,
however, systolic and diastolic measurements had improved compared
with those preoperatively. Conclusion: Resting left ventricular
long axis function is abnormal in patients with combined coronary
artery and peripheral vascular disease. It is unaffected by
anesthesia but deteriorates with aortic or iliac clamping, although
blood pressure remains unchanged. It promptly improves with
unclamping after successful peripheral arterial reconstruction.
Thus, even in apparently stable coronary artery disease, resting
subendocardial function is labile, showing pronounced alterations
with changing after-load, even when arterial pressure itself does
not change. Comments: Changes in after-load can rapidly be
effected in the Circulator Long-Boot. Setting the Circulator Boot
heart monitor to deliver boot compressions during systole increases
after-load. Setting the monitor to deliver compressions in diastole
and to release the leg in presystole decreases after-load. Similar
hemodynamic changes are seen here with clamping the aorta or iliac
arteries. See Dillon 1998 above.
- Ho CK, Sun MP, Au TW, Chiu CS: Pneumatic pump reduces leg wound complications in cardiac patients. Asian Cardiovasc Thorac Ann 14:452-7, 2006. Leg wound complications at the site of vein harvest for coronary artery bypass graft, although infrequent, cause significant morbidity. Pneumatic pressure therapy is valuable in venous and lymphatic diseases, but its usefulness after leg vein harvest has not been determined. A prospective randomized controlled trial was conducted on 200 patients, half of whom had sequential pneumatic leg pump therapy postoperatively. Wound healing, extent of lower limb edema, patient satisfaction, and the financial implications of pneumatic pressure therapy were assessed. In the study group, 71 patients had satisfactory wound healing vs. 23 in the control group. The leg wound infection rate in the study group was 3% vs. 15% in the control group ( p = 0.003). Lower limb edema was significantly reduced in the study group in the early postoperative period ( p < 0.05), and the mean postoperative length of hospital stay was reduced by 2.6 days in patients given pneumatic pressure therapy ( p = 0.003). The sequential pneumatic leg pump is an effective, inexpensive, and convenient device that reduces leg wound complications after coronary artery bypass grafting.
Comments: Ascending TEDS, of course, would be contraindicated if edema is associated with ischemia. Therapy with the Circulator Boot may both decrease edema and increase leg perfusion.
- Kakkos SK, Griffin M, Geroulakos G, Nicolaides AN: The efficacy of a new portable sequential compression device (SCD Express) in preventing venous stasis. J Vasc Surg 42:296-303, 2005. Abstract: OBJECTIVE: It has been previously shown that the SCD Response Compression System, by sensing the postcompression refill time of the lower limbs, delivers more compression cycles over time, resulting in as much as a 76% increase in the total volume of blood expelled per hour. Extended indications for pneumatic compression have necessitated the introduction of portable devices. The aim of our study was to test the hemodynamic effectiveness of a new portable sequential compression system (the SCD Express), which has the ability to detect the individual refill time of the two lower limbs separately. METHODS: This was an open, controlled trial with 30 normal volunteers. The new SCD Express was compared with the SCD Response Compression System in the supine and semirecumbent positions. The refilling time sensed by the device was compared with that determined from velocity recordings of the superficial femoral vein using duplex ultrasonography. Baseline and augmented flow velocity and volume flow, including the total volume of blood expelled per hour during compression with the SCD Express, were compared with those produced by the SCD Response compression system in the same volunteers and positions. RESULTS: Both devices significantly increased venous flow velocity as much as 2.26 times baseline in supine position and 2.67 times baseline in semirecumbent position (all P < .001). There was a linear relationship between duplex ultrasonography-derived refill time and the SCD Express-derived refill time in both the supine (r = 0.39, P = .03) and semirecumbent (r = 0.71, P < .001) positions but not with the SCD Response. Refill time measured by the SCD Express device was significantly shorter and the cycle rate higher in comparison with the SCD Response in both positions. The single-cycle flow velocity and volume flow parameters generated by the two devices were similar in both positions. However, median (interquartile range) total volume of blood expelled per hour was slightly higher with the SCD Express device in the supine position (7206 mL/h [range, 5042-8437] vs 6712 mL/h [4941-10,676]; P = .85) and semirecumbent position (4588 mL/h [range, 3721-6252] vs 4262 mL/h [3520-5831]; P = .22). Peak volume of blood expelled per hour by the SCD Express device in the semirecumbent position was significantly increased by 10% in comparison with the SCD Response (P = .03). CONCLUSIONS: Flow velocity and volume flow enhancement by the SCD Response and SCD Express were essentially similar. The latter, a portable device with optional battery power that detects the individual refill time of the lower limbs separately, is anticipated to be associated with improved overall compliance and therefore optimized thromboprophylaxis. Studies testing its potential for improved efficacy in preventing deep vein thrombosis are justified.
- Kakkos SK, Geroulakos G, Nicolaides AN:
Improvement of the walking ability in intermittent claudication due
to superficial femoral artery occlusion with supervised exercise
and pneumatic foot and calf compression: a randomised controlled
trial. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg 30:164-75, 2005. OBJECTIVES:
To compare the effect of unsupervised exercise, supervised exercise
and intermittent pneumatic foot and calf compression (IPC) on the
claudication distance, lower limb arterial haemodynamics and
quality of life of patients with intermittent claudication.
METHODS: Thirty-four eligible patients with stable intermittent
claudication were randomised to IPC (n = 13, 3h/d for 6 months),
supervised exercise (n = 12, three hourly sessions/week for 6
months) or unsupervised exercise (n = 9). In each patient, initial
claudication distance (ICD), absolute claudication distance (ACD),
resting ankle brachial pressure index (ABPI), and resting
hyperaemic calf arterial inflow were measured before, 6 weeks, 6
months and 1 year after randomisation. Quality of life was assessed
with the short form (SF)-36, walking impairment (WIQ) and
intermittent claudication questionnaires (ICQ). RESULTS: Compared
with unsupervised exercise, both IPC and supervised exercise,
increased ICD and ACD, up to 2.83 times. IPC increased arterial
inflow (p < 0.05 at 6 weeks) and ABPI. Supervised exercise
decreased arterial inflow and increased ABPI (p < 0.05 at 6
months). Unsupervised exercise had no effect on arterial inflow or
ABPI. IPC improved significantly the ICQ score and the speed score
of the WIQ, while supervised exercise improved the WIQ claudication
severity score. At 1 year clinical effectiveness of supervised
exercise and IPC was largely preserved. CONCLUSIONS: IPC, by
augmenting leg perfusion, achieved improvement in walking distance
comparable with supervised exercise. Long-term results in a larger
number of patients will provide valuable information on the optimal
treatment modality of intermittent claudication.Comments: This
article is included not because it describes the use of equipment
similar to the Circulator Boot, or because it describes impressive
therapeutic results or because it deserves attention because of its
size; it does not. Rather, it is included because the Aetna
Insurance company quotes it as one of a few articles supporting
pneumatic boot therapy in patients with arterial disease. Likely,
Aetna was influenced by the title of the article which included the
popular terms: "randomized" and "controlled". These patients were
described as having claudication in association with disease of the
superficial femornal artery. As with Ramaswami et al discussed
below, the ArtAssist pneumatic device used inflated to 120 mmHg
first a foot cuff and then a second later a calf cuff with a
frequency of 3 compressions a minute. Of 151 patients screened for
the study, 13 were allocated to the IPC treatments and 9 were
available for analysis at six months. 117 were initially excluded
to produce a study population with significant claudication free of
other conditions (27 lines in their methods section) that might
make the study difficult. In patients with calf arterial pressures
less than 120 mm Hg, the device potentially blocks and even might
reverse arterial inflow into the lower leg while successfully
expelling venous blood. In patients in whom the arterial inflow was
not reversed, emptying the veins increases the A/V pressure
gradient when the pump was deflated. In contrast, Circulator Boot
therapy in such patients would have delivered more compressions
(either every beat or every other heartbeat), utilized a full leg
bag thus treating the thigh also and provided concurrent therapy to
the heart.
- Katz ES, Tunick PA and Kronzon I: Observations of
coronary flow augmentation and balloon function during intraaortic
balloon counterpulation using transesophageal
echocardiography. Am J Cardiol 69: 1635-1639, 1992.
...&Quot; Noninvasively, transesophageal
echocardiography"...(TEE)..." has demonstrated efficacy in enabling
visualization of the proximal left coronary artery and in recording
coronary blood flow velocity"... In 6 studied patients..."Peak
diastolic coronary blood flow velocity increased by a mean of 117%
(range 62 to 287) during balloon inflation (P=0.002). Furthermore,
coronary flow velocity integral increased by a mean of 87% (range
43 to 176; P=0.003)." Balloon function and position also
evaluated.
- Kavros SJ, Delis KT, Turner NS, Voll AE, Liedl DA, Gloviczki P, Rooke TW.: Improving limb salvage in critical ischemia with intermittent pneumatic compression: a controlled study with 18-month follow-up. J Vasc Surg 47(3):543-9,2008.
BACKGROUND: Intermittent pneumatic compression (IPC) is an effective method of leg inflow enhancement and amelioration of claudication in patients with peripheral arterial disease. This study evaluated the clinical efficacy of IPC in patients with chronic critical limb ischemia, tissue loss, and nonhealing wounds of the foot after limited foot surgery (toe or transmetatarsal amputation) on whom additional arterial revascularization had been exhausted. METHODS: Performed in a community and multidisciplinary health care clinic (1998 through 2004), this retrospective study comprises 2 groups. Group 1 (IPC group) consisted of 24 consecutive patients, median age 70 years (interquartile range [IQR], 68.7-71.3) years, who received IPC for tissue loss and nonhealing amputation wounds of the foot attributable to critical limb ischemia in addition to wound care. Group 2 (control group) consisted of 24 consecutive patients, median age 69 years (IQR, 65.7-70.3 years), who received wound care for tissue loss and nonhealing amputation wounds of the foot due to critical limb ischemia, without use of IPC. Stringent exclusion criteria applied. Group allocation of patients depended solely on their willingness to undergo IPC therapy. Vascular assessment included determination of the resting ankle-brachial pressure index, transcutaneous oximetry (TcPO(2)), duplex graft surveillance, and foot radiography. Outcome was considered favorable if complete healing and limb salvage occurred, and adverse if the patient had to undergo a below knee amputation subsequent to failure of wound healing. Follow-up was 18 months. Wound care consisted of weekly débridement and biologic dressings. IPC was delivered at an inflation pressure of 85 to 95 mm Hg, applied for 2 seconds with rapid rise (0.2 seconds), 3 cycles per minute; three 2-hourly sessions per day were requested. Compliance was closely monitored. RESULTS: Baseline differences in demography, cardiovascular risk factors (diabetes mellitus, smoking, hypertension, dyslipidemia, renal impairment), and severity of peripheral arterial disease (ankle-brachial indices, TcPO(2), prior arterial reconstruction) were not significant. The types of local foot amputation that occurred in the two groups were not significantly different. In the control group, foot wounds failed to heal in 20 patients (83%) and they underwent a below knee amputation; the remaining four (17%, 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.59%-32.7%) had complete healing and limb salvage. In the IPC group, 14 patients (58%, 95% CI, 37.1%-79.6%) had complete foot wound healing and limb salvage, and 10 (42%) underwent below knee amputation for nonhealing foot wounds. Wound healing and limb salvage were significantly better in the IPC group (P < .01, chi(2)). Compared with the IPC group, the odds ratio of limb loss in the control group was 7.0. On study completion, TcPO(2) on sitting was higher in the IPC group than in the control group (P = .0038). CONCLUSION: IPC used as an adjunct to wound care in patients with chronic critical limb ischemia and nonhealing amputation wounds/tissue loss improves the likelihood of wound healing and limb salvage when established treatment alternatives in current practice are lacking. This controlled study adds to the momentum of IPC clinical efficacy in critical limb ischemia set by previously published case series, compelling the pursuit of large scale multicentric level 1 studies to substantiate its actual clinical role, relative indications, and to enhance our insight into the pertinent physiologic mechanisms.
- Keith SL, McLaughlin DJ, Anderson FA Jr, Cardullo PA, Jones
CE, Rohrer MJ, Cutler BS: Do graduated compression
stockings and pneumatic boots have an additive effect on the peak
velocity of venous blood flow? Arch Surg 127(6):727-30,
1992. Graduated compression stockings and intermittent pneumatic
compression boots reduce the incidence of deep vein thrombosis.
Recent studies suggest that the simultaneous use of these devices
may have a synergistic prophylactic effect; however, conflicting
reports also exist. Using duplex imaging, we analyzed the effect on
peak venous velocity in the superficial femoral vein produced by
the individual and simultaneous use of graduated compression
stockings and intermittent pneumatic compression boots. Normal
volunteers and postoperative patients were examined. The use of
intermittent pneumatic compression boots significantly increased
the peak venous velocity relative to rest, whereas the use of
graduated compression stockings did not alter the peak venous
velocity. Also, the addition of graduated compression stockings to
legs already being treated with intermittent pneumatic compression
boots did not produce a further augmentation of peak venous
velocity. This study demonstrates that the simultaneous use of
graduated compression stockings and intermittent pneumatic
compression boots does not produce a synergistic augmentation of
peak venous velocity in the superficial femoral vein.
- Kern MJ, Henry RH, Lembo N, Park RC, Lujan MS, Ferry D and
O'Rourke RA: Effects of pulsed external augmentation of
diastolic pressure on coronary and systemic hemodynamics in
patients with coronary artery disease. Am Heart J
110:727-735, 1985. Fourteen men with coronary heart disease and
normal left ventricular function were studied. Peak diastolic blood
pressure was augmented to within 5mm Hg of systolic pressure.
External counterpulsation increased mean arterial pressure from
108±11 to 114±12 mm Hg (P<0.01) and the
diastolic-pressure time index from 440±51 to 498±82
units (P><0.01) with no change in the systolic-pressure time
index, absolute coronary sinus or great vein cardiac vein blood
flow. External diastolic pressure augmentation did not affect heart
rate, right heart hemodynamics, cardiac output, or calculated
oxygen oxygen consumption. An unanticipated finding was a greater
than or equal to 10% reduction in peak systolic pressure during
external diastolic pressure augmentation in 8 of the 14 patients.
The increase in the diastolic pressure-time/systolic pressure-time
index suggests that subendocardial perfusion may be favorably
influenced by diastolic pressure augmentation. Their leg pressure
was applied 240 msec after the Q-wave of the EKG and was applied
for 340 msec. Doppler studies showed a reversal of flow in the
femoral artery.Comments: This is not end-diastolic pumping. For
a patient with a pulse rate of 80 for example, the R-R interval
would be 750 msec and their leg compression would end 170 msec
before the next QRS complex.
- Knight MTN and Dawson K: Effect of intermittent
compression of the arms on deep vein thrombosis in the legs.
Lancet 2: 1265, 1976. Arm pumping decreased euglobulin lysis time
and was associated with a decrease in leg thrombi.
- Koch CA: External leg compression in the treatment
of vascular disease.Angiology 48, Number 5, Part 2: S3-S15,
1997. Author's summary: In summary, external compression of the
limbs is a mode of therapy which has enjoyed a long history in the
treatment of venous and arterial disease. Evidence suggests that
its beneficial effects are mediated through enhancement of venous
and arterial blood flow, promotion of vasodilatation, enhancement
of fibrinolysis and, in the case of obstructive arterial disease,
promotion of the development of collateral circulation. The utility
of external leg compression in the prevention of deep venous
thrombosis and in the management of chronic venous stasis disease
has been well documented, and it has become an accepted treatment
for these disorders. The use of pneumatic compression in the
treatment of atherosclerotic peripheral vascular and cardiovascular
disease is less widespread and their indications less well defined,
though the work of a few investigators in each of these areas show
striking benefits of the technique. Further investigation in these
areas is warranted. Potential benefits to patients of external limb
compression therapy include its noninvasive nature, its ability to
be applied in the outpatient setting, and long-term cost savings
through possible avoidance of hospitalization and invasive
procedures. Comments: The author takes us back to Sir James
Murray in 1812 and follows the development of boot therapy over the
next 183 years. She is referring to intermittent pneumatic
compression boots... not constant pressure stockings or
wrappings.
- Kumbasar SD, Semiz E, Sancaktar O, Yalcinkaya S, Ermis C and
Deger N: Concomitant use of intraaortic balloon
counterpulsation and streptokinase in acute anterior myocardial
infarction. Angiology 50: 465-471, 1999. Authors' summary:
Using a prospective, nonrandomized design, the authors sought to
determine whether concomitant use of intraaortic balloon
counterpulsation (IABP) and streptokinase in acute anterior
myocardial infarction (MI) would improve the in-hospital mortality
rate and angiographic findings. The study included 45 patients with
an acute anterior MI. All patients received intravenous
streptokinase. Among these, 25 had concomitant IABP while the
remaining 20 had streptokinase alone. All patients underwent
cardiac catheterization. Patients treated with IABP had a
significantly higher frequency of thrombolysis in myocardial
infarction (TIMI) grade 3 flow (n: 11; 44% vs n:1 5%, p<0.05),
and there was a trend toward a lower in-hospital mortality rate in
the IABP group (n: 0; 0% vs N:3; 15%, p=0.08). The angiographic
presence of thrombus image and grade >/= 2 coronary collateral
circulation to the infarct-related coronary artery for the IABP and
non-IABP groups did not differ significantly. The preliminary
results of this study suggest that concomitant use of IABP and
streptokinase in acute anterior MI increases the incidence of TIMI
grade 3 flow and may have decreased the in-hospital mortality rate
without unacceptable rates of vascular or hemorrhagic
complications. Comments: Complications of their IABP included
bleeding and groin hematomas requiring less than 3 units of blood
transfusion in 4 patients, balloon rupture in one patient (another
inserted without difficulty) and lower extremity ischemia resolving
after removal of the balloon in 2 patients. External
counterpulsation, of course, has no complications and can be
applied more quickly. See Dillon (1998) above more more discussion
on IABP vs external counterpulsation. This article by Kumbasar et
al is included hopefully to encourage a similar study with the use
of the Circulator Boot.
- Labropoulos N, Watson WC, Mansour MA, Kang SS, Littooy FN,
Baker WH: Acute effects of intermittent compression on
popliteal artery blood flow. Arch Surg 133:1072-5, 1998.
Objectives: To investigate the immediate effects of
intermittent pneumatic foot and calf compression (IPFCC) on
popliteal artery blood flow in symptom-free volunteers and to
determine the reproducibility of color flow duplex imaging in the
popliteal artery. Results: Including all types of
variability, the popliteal artery blood flow varied from 8% to 39%
with a mean value of 19%. Since the diameter of the artery was
obtained with less than 5% variability, the time average mean
velocity was responsible for the high variation in flow. During
application of the IPFCC, the popliteal artery blood flow increased
significantly in all subjects (P<0.001). The mean increase in
flow was 2.4 times baseline values. The diameter of the arteries
remained unchanged while the time average velocity increased
significantly (P><0.001). This velocity increase was due to
marked elevation in the peak systolic and end diastolic velocities
and diminution of the reverse-flow component, as well as a
prolongation of the forward flow during diastole. After cessation
of the pump, flow returned to baseline levels (P=.41). Comments:
The authors placed inflatable 22- and 12-cm neoprene cuffs on the
dorsum of the foot and the muscle mass of the calf, respectively.
Their pump inflated to 120 mm Hg for 3 seconds at 12-second
intervals with the foot cuff preceding the calf cuff by 2 seconds.
Such timing maximizes venous return with this equipment. This
equipment differs from the Circulator Mini-Boot in that (1) it
compresses the lower leg at a pressure well above systolic pressure
in many ischemic legs; (2) its longer compressions [3 seconds Vs
0.34 seconds for the Mini-Boot] may effectively block arterial
inflow during its compression phase; (3) it does not encompass the
entire lower leg so that its compressions send a pulse wave both
proximally and distally with the distal pulse wave potentially
stretching or breaking venous valves; (4) it is not
cardiosynchronous; (5) it does not lend itself well to the usage of
local antibiotics and foot soaks; (6) the authors offer no data
showing that its usage has favorably altered blood flow in ischemic
legs.
- Labropoulos N.1; Wierks C.1; Suffoletto B.1:
Intermittent pneumatic compression for the treatment of lower
extremity arterial disease: a systematic review. Vascular
Medicine 7: 141-148, 2002. Abstract: This study aimed to identify
the role of intermittent pneumatic compression in treating
peripheral arterial disease and to investigate the types of
treatment programs that are most effective. Data was sourced from
English-language articles which were identified by a computer
search using MEDLINE from 1966 to 2001, followed by extensive
bibliography review. Studies were included if they contained
pertinent material involving a compression device and arterial flow
dynamics in lower limbs. A total of 26 English-language studies
were identified that met the inclusion criteria. The diverse
patient criteria and methods used in the studies provided an
opportunity to examine the effectiveness of each, but made it
difficult to compare one study with another. To assist in focusing
on overall trends in improvement, patient type and treatment type
disparities must be identified. In conclusion, it is evident that
an intermittent pneumatic compression program appears promising and
may be used in patients with severe peripheral arterial disease who
are not candidates for revascularization using surgery or
percutaneous angioplasty. It is now the goal to establish
randomized, prospective, controlled trials to clarify the most
beneficial regimen for treating such disease.
- Labropoulos N, Leon LR, Bhatti A et al: Hemodynamic effects of intermittent pneumatic compression in patients with critical limb ischemia. J Vas Surg 42:710-6, 2005. BACKGROUND: Traditional teaching assumes that the distal arterial tree is maximally dilated in patients with critical limb ischemia (CLI). Endovascular or arterial bypass procedures are the commonly used interventions to increase distal perfusion. However, other forms of treatment such as spinal cord stimulation or intermittent pneumatic compression (IPC) have been shown to improve limb salvage rates. This prospective study was designed to determine if the use of IPC increases popliteal, gastrocnemial, collateral arterial, and skin blood flow in patients with CLI. METHODS: Twenty limbs with CLI in 20 patients (mean age, 74 years) were evaluated with duplex ultrasound scans and laser Doppler fluxmetry in the semi-erect position before, during, and after IPC. One pneumatic cuff was applied on the foot and the other on the calf. The maximum inflation pressure was 120 mm Hg and was applied for 3 seconds at three cycles per minute. All patients had at least two-level disease by arteriography. Fourteen limbs were characterized as inoperable, and six were considered marginal for reconstruction. Flow volumes were measured in the popliteal, medial gastrocnemial, and a genicular collateral artery. Skin blood flux was measured on the dorsum of the foot at the same time. RESULTS: Significant flow increase during the application of IPC was found in all three arteries (18/20 limbs) compared with baseline values (P < .02). The highest change was seen in the popliteal, followed by the gastrocnemial and the collateral artery. After the cessation of IPC, the flow returned to baseline. This was attributed to the elevation of time average velocity, as the diameter of the arteries remained unchanged. The skin blood flux increased significantly as well (P < .03). In the two limbs without an increase in the arterial or skin blood flow, significant popliteal vein reflux was found. Both limbs were amputated shortly after. CONCLUSIONS: IPC increases axial, muscular, collateral, and skin blood flow in patients with CLI and may be beneficial to those who are not candidates for revascularization. Patients with significant venous reflux may not benefit from IPC. This supports the theory that one of the mechanisms by which IPC enhances flow is by increasing the arteriovenous pressure gradient.Comments: These authors are using the same apparatus critiqued above. Here they give some vascular data. In their discussion, they include the long term success of Vella et al (below) inferring the success was obtained with the same IPC apparatus they utilized; not so... Vella et al reported on their usage of the Circulator Boot.
- Landis EM and Hitzrot LH: Treatment of peripheral
vascular disease by means of suction pressure. Ann Intern
Med 3:1, 1935.
- Landis EM: Results of treatment with the Landis Suction-Pressure Boot. The Metabolic Service of Edward Dillon. Philadelphia General Hospital. Penna Med J 38:579-583, 1935. Objects of treatment (usual treatment having failed): (1) to promote healing of trophic lesions and (2) to allay ischemic pain.
Comments: Not too bad for an era before antibiotics. They did better in situations not involving infection (pain relief) as opposed to ulcers and osteomyelitis. Edward Dillon was the father of Richard Dillon (born 1933), inventor of the Circulator Boot.Patient Category Results Diabetes, arteriosclerosis Good ........................................14 chronic ulcer.............,....6 Ulcers healed....... 3 superficial gangrene........4 gangrenous plaque sep-
arated and healed..4pain...............................5 pain relieved ........ 7 Thrombo-angitis obliterans...............3 Encouraging but incomplete..........1 Arteriosclerosis with ulcer................2 Failure.........................................3
osteomyelitis presentAverage number of hours of
treatment 21.5
- Lawson WE, Hui JCK, Soroff HS, Zheng ZS, Kayden DS, Sasvary
D, Atkins H and Cohn PF: Efficacy of enhanced external
counterpulsation in treatment of angina pectoris. AM J
Cardiol 70: 859-862, 1992. Eighteen patients with chronic angina
despite medical and surgical RX treated 1 hour daily for 36 hours.
All patients improved in symptoms and generally decreased their
need for meds. 16 were completely relieved. Serial thallium stress
testing showed complete resolution of ischemic defects in 12
patients (67%), reduction in area of ischemia in 2 (11%), and no
change in 4 (22%). The exercise duration of max stress testing
improved from 8.14+/-0.71 to 9.72+/-77 minutes (P <: 0.005)
although the double product did not change significantly. Authors
claim that EECP uses thigh balloons and sequenced balloon inflation
thus improving their diastolic augmentation over previously
available methods. Exclusion criteria included clinical CHF*,
aortic insufficiency, recent myocardial infarction (last 3 months)*
significant ventricular ectopy* or atrial fibrillation, nonischemic
cardiomyopathy*, severe occlusive peripheral vascular disease*,
recurrent deep vein thrombophlebitis*, systemic hypertension, and a
bleeding diathesis. Comments: * Items have not been
contraindications for therapy with the Circulator Boot.
- Lawson WE, Hui JC, Zheng ZS, Oster Z, Katz JP, Diggs P,
Burger L, Cohn CD, Soroff HS and Cohn PF: Three-year
sustained benefit from enhanced external counterpulsation in
chronic angina pectoris. Am J Cardiology 75:840-841, 1995.
Exclusion criteria similar to study above. Follow-up of 18 patients
with positive thallium stress tests who were given 36 hours of
EECP. Studied within a week after the treatment, 11 patients no
longer had evidence of ischemia with the same cardiac workload,
three had less ischemia and four were unchanged. Over the next
three years, 8 patients received supplemental EECP. At the three
yar follow-up, 8 of the 14 patients with initial improvement
remained negative, one was lost to follow-up, one refused follow-up
stress testing, two had reverted to positive tests, one had a
myocardial infarction and one had a coronary bypass graft (CABG).
Of the four with ischemia before and after their initial EECP, two
had continued abnormal tests, one had PTCA and one had CABG.
Comments: It is interesting to note the qualification about no
ischemia at the same cardiac workload. We commonly find less
angina in our patients treated with the Circulator Boot at the same
walking distance.... but as their claudication improves, their
walking distance and walking speed may increase still producing
angina at the greater cardiac workload.
- Lawson WE, Hui JCK, Zheng ZS, Burger L, Jiang L, Lillis O,
Soroff HS and Cohn PF: Can angiographic findings predict
which coronary patients will benefit from enhanced external
counterpulsation? Am J Cardiol 77:1107-1109, 1996. This
study evaluated and appeared to confirm the hypothesis that a
patent vascular conduit was necessary for the efficacy of this
treatment via transmission of the augmented diastolic perfusion
pressure to the distal coronary artery. The patients were given 35
hours of EECP treatment as five hours a week over seven weeks.
Perfusion defects improved in 18 of 19 (95%) patients with 1-vessel
disease, in 17 of 19 (90%) patients with 2-vessel disease and 5 of
12 (42%) with 3-vessel disease. EECP may offer promise in some
patients in whom complete revascularization is not feasible; in
such cases, palliative PTCA or CABG may decrease the coronary
artery disease extent to residual 1- or 2- vessel disease that
might benefit from counterpulsation.
- Lawson WE, Hui JCK, Zheng ZS, Burger L, Jiang L, Lillis O,
Oster Z, Soroff H and Cohn PF: Improved exercise
tolerance following enhanced external counterpulsation: cardiac or
peripheral effect? Cardiology 87:271-275, 1996. Twenty-two
of 27 (81%) patients treated with EECP improved their exercise
tolerance and 21 of the 27 improved their radionuclide stress
perfusion images. Post-EECP maximum exercise heart rate and blood
pressure, while demonstrating a linear relation with exercise
duration, did not increase significantly despite the increased
exercise duration. This, the authors suggest, may mean that the
increase in exercise duration after treatment was due to both an
improved myocardial perfusion and altered exercise hemodynamics.
EECP thus appears to exert a "training" effect, decreasing
peripheral vascular resistance and heart rate response to exercise.
Coronary disease patients may improve their exercise tolerance
after EECP because of both improved myocardial perfusion and a
decrease in cardiac work load. There were 26 men and one woman
in the study. The patients received 35 hours of treatment (1-2
hours daily). The increase in exercise duration was highly
significant but modest increasing from 7.17 ± 0.53 to 8.84
± 0.50 minutes. The patients who had an improved perfusion
image after treatment had higher exercise durations both before and
after treatment than the group as a whole: 7.22 ±0.63
increasing to 9.12 ±0.60 minutes.
- Lawson WE, Hui JCK, Oster ZH, Zheng ZS, Cabahug C, Katz JP,
Dervan JP, Burger L, Jiang L, Soroff HS, Cohn PF:Enhanced
external counterpulsation as an adjunct to revascularization in
unstable angina. Clin Cardiol 20, 178-180, 1997. Despite
intensive risk factor modification, a patient required two surgical
coronary revascularizations and seven multivessel angioplasties
over a 26 month period, demonstrating recurrent unstable angina and
persistent thallium perfusion defects despite revascularization.
Post EECP, angina was relieved, thallium defects were resolved, and
the patient remained asymptomatic for 36 months.
- Lawson WE, Hui JC et al; for the IEPR investigators: Effect of enhanced external counterpulsation on medically refractory angina patients with erectile dysfunction. Int J Clin Pract. 61:757-62, 2007. Patients with refractory angina often suffer from erectile dysfunction. Enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) decreases symptoms of angina, and increases nitric oxide release. This study evaluated the effect of EECP on sexual function in men with severe angina. The International Index of Erectile Function (IIEF) was used to assess erectile function of severe angina patients enroled in the International EECP Patient Registry. Their symptom status, medication use, adverse clinical events and quality of life were also recorded before and after completing a course of EECP. A cohort of 120 men (mean age 65.0+/-9.7) was enroled. The men had severe coronary disease with 69% having a prior myocardial infarction, 90% prior coronary artery bypass graft or percutaneous coronary intervention, 49% with three vessel coronary artery disease, 86% were not candidates for further revascularisation, 71% hypertensive, 83% dyslipidaemia, 42% diabetes mellitus, 75% smoking and 68% using nitrates. Functional status was low with a mean Duke Activity Status Inventory score of 16.6+/-14.8. After 35 h of EECP anginal status improved in 89%, and functional status in 63%. A comparison of the IIEF scores pre- and post-EECP therapy demonstrated a significant improvement in erectile function from 10.0+/-1.0 to 11.8+/-1.0 (p=0.003), intercourse satisfaction (4.2+/-0.5 to 5.0+/-0.5, p=0.009) and overall satisfaction (4.7+/-0.3 to 5.3+/-0.3, p=0.001). However, there were no significant changes in orgasmic function (4.2+/-0.4 to 4.6+/-0.4, p=0.19) or sexual desire (5.3+/-0.2 to 5.5+/-0.2). The findings suggest that EECP therapy is associated with improvement in erectile function in men with refractory angina. Comments: Male patients treated with the Circulator Boot commented often enough about having a return of nocturnal spontaneous erections for us to start a study that included an extension of the boot to include the penis in the treatment program. Early results were promising but referrals for the study ceased with the introduction of Viagra.
- Lawson WE, Hui JCK et al: Predictors of Benefit in Angina Patients One Year after Completing Enhanced External Counterpulsation: Initial Responders to Treatment versus Nonresponders
Cardiology 103:201-206, 2005. Abstract: Enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) has been shown to reduce Canadian Cardiovascular Society angina class. This study examines the factors that affect the reduction at 1 year, especially in patients who do not demonstrate an initial response. The data of 2,007 consecutive patients enrolled in the International EECP Patient Registry were analyzed. After 36.6 ± 4.9 h of EECP, angina was reduced by at least one class in 82.7%. At 1 year, 35.4% of initial nonresponders and 70.6% of responders remained improved by at least one angina class and free of major adverse cardiovascular events. Multivariate predictors of 1-year benefit are initial response to treatment (odds ratio 4.5, 95% CI 3.5-5.8), baseline angina class compared with class IV (odds ratios: class I 2.1, CI 0.93-4.81; class II 0.62, CI 0.43-0.87; class III 0.80, CI 0.62-1.01) and no history of congestive heart failure (odds ratio 1.41, CI 1.14-1.74).
- Lawson WE, Solver MA, Hui JCK, Kennard ED, Kelsey SF for the IEPR investigators: Angina patients with diastolic versus systolic heart failure demonstrate comparable immediate and one-year benefit from enhanced external counterpulsation. Journal of Cardiac Failure 11:61-66, 2005.
Abstract: Background: Enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) is effective in treating angina in coronary artery disease patients. Whether EECP produces similar immediate and sustained benefits and freedom from adverse events (MACE) at 1 year in patients with severe systolic dysfunction versus diastolic dysfunction is unknown. Methods and results: Data of 746 angina patients with a history of heart failure enrolled in the International EECP Registry were divided into 2 groups: left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) =35% (S) and LVEF >35% (D). Mean LVEF was 51.0 ± 10.2% in diastolic dysfunction (n = 391) versus 26.3 ± 6.9% in systolic dysfunction (n = 355). At baseline, 92.0% of diastolic dysfunction and 90.9% of systolic had Canadian Cardiovascular Society Class III/IV angina with similar number of anginal episodes and nitroglycerin use. After 32 hours of EECP, angina was reduced by =1 class in 71.9% of diastolic versus 72.2% of systolic with similar decreases in anginal episodes and nitroglycerin use. At 1-year 78.1% of diastolic and 75.8% of systolic have less angina than pre-EECP. MACE at 1 year was also comparable (24.4 versus 23.8%). Conclusions: The benefits of EECP in heart failure patients were similar regardless of diastolic or systolic dysfunction. The improvement was sustained at 1 year with similar MACE.
- Lippmann HI, Fishman LM, Farrar RH, Bernstein RK and Zybvert
PA: Edema control in the management of disabling chronic
venous insufficiency. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 75:436-441,
1994. A 15-year retrospective study assessing the biomedical and
socioeconomic rationale of edema control in disabling chronic
venous insufficiency... 2317 patients... Unna boot used for
ulcerations and compression hosiery used for prevention of
ulcerations... Approximate overall healing rate 60.9%.... The Unna
boot is relatively cheap but does require regular clinic visits for
replacement.
- Liu K, Chen LE, Seaber AV, Urbaniak JR: Influences
of inflation rate and duration on vasodilatory effect by
intermittent pneumatic compression in distant skeletal
muscle. J Orthop Res 17(3):415-20, 1999. Previous study has
demonstrated that application of intermittent pneumatic compression
on legs can cause vasodilation in distant skeletal muscle at the
microcirculation level. This study evaluated the influence of
inflation rate and peak-pressure duration on the vasodilatory
effects of intermittent pneumatic compression. The cremaster
muscles of 50 male rats were exposed and divided into five groups
of 10 each. A specially designed intermittent pneumatic-compression
device was applied in a medial-lateral fashion to both legs of all
rats for 60 minutes, with an inflation rate and peak-pressure
duration of 0.5 and 5 seconds, respectively, in group A, 5 and 0
seconds in group B, 5 and 5 seconds in group C, 10 and 0 seconds in
group D, and 10 and 5 seconds in group E. Diameters of arterial
segments were measured in vessels of three size categories (10-20,
21-40, and 41-70 microm) for 120 minutes. The results showed that
the greatest increase in diameter was produced by intermittent
pneumatic compression with the shortest inflation rate (0.5
seconds). A moderate increase resulted from compression with an
inflation rate of 5 seconds, and no effective vasodilation occurred
during compression with the longest inflation rate (10 seconds).
When the groups with different inflation rates but the same
peak-pressure duration were compared, there was a significant
difference between any two groups among groups A, C, and E and
between groups B and D. When the groups with different
peak-pressure durations but the same inflation rate were compared,
compression with a peak-pressure duration of 5 seconds caused a
generally similar degree of diameter change as did compression
without inflation at peak pressure. The findings suggest that
inflation rate plays an important role in the modulation of distant
microcirculation induced by intermittent pneumatic compression
whereas peak-pressure duration does not significantly influence the
vasodilatory effects of the compression. This may be due to the
fact that rapid inflation produces a significant increase in shear
stress on the vascular wall, which stimulates vascular endothelium
to release nitric oxide, causing systemic vasodilation.
Comments: The authors went on to show that the vasodilation could
be completely blocked by an inhibitor of nitric oxide synthase,
NG-monomethyl-L-arginine implying that the production of nitric
oxide was involved in the positive influence of intermittent
pneumatic compression on circulation (J Orthop Res 17:88-95, 1999
and J Appl Physiol 92(2):559-66, 2002). The Circulator Boot, of
course, also applies pressure for a short duration, commonly 0.42
seconds. While pumping on one leg, we have been able to document
improved flow in the opposite leg by various techniques. In our
case #143 in our case history section, we used NMR spectroscopy. In
another case, we noted 100% oxygen by mask significantly raised
polarographic subcutaneous PO2 levels faster when the opposite leg
was treated in the Circulator Boot. In case #182, we show how pulse
volume curves on the arms change with pumping on the legs. Many
things happen with Circulator Boot therapy making the mechanism why
remote tissue arterial flow increases unclear: cardiac output
increases and venous blood and lymph fluid are expressed from the
legs increasing volume presumably elsewhere. In this paper, the
generation of nitric oxide is implicated and the desirability of
rapid pulsations in promoting the effect is seen.
- Loh PH, Louis AA, Windram J, Rigby AS, Cook J, Hurren S, Nikolay NP, Caplin J, Cleland JG: The immediate and long-term outcome of enhanced external counterpulsation in treatment of chronic stable refractory angina. J Intern Med 259:276-84. 2006. BACKGROUND: Treatment of angina recalcitrant to conventional pharmacological therapy and revascularization remains problematic. Safe, effective and affordable treatments with high patient acceptability are desirable. Enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) may fulfil these criteria better than many other proposed interventions. OBJECTIVE: To examine the immediate and long-term effect of EECP in treatment of chronic stable refractory angina. DESIGN: Prospective observational study of consecutive patients treated with EECP and follow-up for 1 year. SETTING: Teaching hospital. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Canadian Cardiovascular Society (CCS) angina grading, weekly angina frequency and glyceryl trinitrate (GTN) use. RESULTS: Sixty-one patients were treated with EECP and 58 completed a course of treatment. Further analysis is confined to those who completed EECP. About 52% of patients suffered from CCS III and IV angina prior to EECP. Immediately post-EECP, angina improved by at least one CCS class in 86% and by two classes in 59%. At 1-year follow-up, sustained improvement in CCS was observed in 78% of the patients. The median weekly angina frequency and GTN use were significantly reduced immediately after EECP [7 (4-14) vs. 1 (0-4) episodes per week and 7 (2-16) vs. 0 (0-2) times per week respectively, P < 0.0001; data in median (interquartile range)]. The reduction was sustained at 1-year follow-up. In 48 patients, their mean exercise time improved significantly after EECP [301 +/- 130 s vs. 379 +/- 147 s, P < 0.0001]. Major adverse treatment-related events were rare. CONCLUSION: This study shows that for patients who fail to respond to conventional measures, a high proportion gain symptomatic benefit from EECP.
- Makhoul RG, Cole CW and McCann RL:Vascular
complications of the intra-aortic balloon pump: an analysis of 436
patients. The Amer Surgeon 59:564-568, 1993. Indications for
balloon therapy: intraoperative pump failure (42%), unstable angina
(24%), preoperative prophylaxis (22%), preoperative shock (9%) and
postoperative support (3%). Vascular complications occurred in 46
patients (10.6%) with leg ischemia, the problem in 40 of the 46.
Only the absence of pedal pulses on admission correlated with an
increase in vascular complications. Comments: Therapy with the
Circulator Boot has not been associated with any such complications
and is more rapidly utilized. We have had no studies to evaluate is
function in the above roles.
- Manchanda A and Soran O: Enhanced external counterpulsation and future directions: step beyond medical management for patients with angina and heart failure. J Am Coll Cardiol 50:1523-31, 2007. Between 25,000 and 75,000 new cases of angina refractory to maximal medical therapy and standard coronary revascularization procedures are diagnosed each year. In addition, heart failure also places an enormous burden on the U.S. health care system, with an estimated economic impact ranging from $20 billion to more than $50 billion per year. The technique of counterpulsation, studied for almost one-half century now, is considered a safe, highly beneficial, low-cost, noninvasive treatment for these angina patients, and now for heart failure patients as well. Recent evidence suggests that enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) therapy may improve symptoms and decrease long-term morbidity via more than 1 mechanism, including improvement in endothelial function, promotion of collateralization, enhancement of ventricular function, improvement in oxygen consumption (VO2), regression of atherosclerosis, and peripheral training effects similar to exercise. Numerous clinical trials in the last 2 decades have shown EECP therapy to be safe and effective for patients with refractory angina with a clinical response rate averaging 70% to 80%, which is sustained up to 5 years. It is not only safe in patients with coexisting heart failure, but also is shown to improve quality of life and exercise capacity and to improve left ventricular function long-term. Interestingly, EECP therapy has been studied for various potential uses other than heart disease, such as restless leg syndrome, sudden deafness, hepatorenal syndrome, erectile dysfunction, and so on. This review summarizes the current evidence for its use in stable angina and heart failure and its future directions. Comments: The systemic effects of booting are frequently surprising. Our Circulator Boot patients have noted improvement in vision, erectile function and a general sense of well-being.
- McCulloch JM, Marler KC, Neal MB and Phifer
TJ:Intermittent pneumatic compression improves venous
ulcer healing. Advances in Wound Care 7:22-26, 1994.
Abstract: The effects of intermittent pneumatic compression on the
healing rates of ulcers in patients with chronic venous
insufficiency were examined in a prospective, controlled study of
22 patients. Patients were randomly assigned to the experimental or
the control group. Both groups received local wound care followed
by application of an Unna boot. In addition, subjects in the
experimental group received intermittent pneumatic compression
(IPC) twice weekly for one hour each session. Healing rates were
reported in square centimeters per day. Data analysis revealed a
mean healing rate of 0.08 cm2 per day for control subjects and
0.15cm2 per day for experimental subjects. Statistical analysis
demonstrated the healing rates of the two groups to be
statistically different. The results appear to indicate that
intermittent compression is beneficial in the management of venous
insufficiency ulcers.Comments: Our bias, of course, is that
intermittent compression is indicated in all patients with stasis
ulcers. Clinicians should compare the effects of the various
devices on the market. Note if they restore transcutaneous PO2
levels. Note what happens to the texture and the turgor of the
pumped areas. Are they softened and reduced in size or are they
left firm with water merely expelled?
- Michaels AD, Barseness GW, Soran O, Kelsey SF, Kennard ED, Hui JC. Lawson WE: Frequency and efficacy of repeat enhanced external counterpulsation for stable angina pectoris (from the International EECP Patient Registry). Am J Cardiol 95:394-7, 2005. Abstract: We assessed the frequency, efficacy, predictors, and long-term success of repeat enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) therapy in relieving angina in a large cohort of patients who had chronic angina pectoris and had undergone a full course of EECP. Within 2 years of the initial course of EECP, the rate of repeat EECP was 18%, which occurred at a mean interval of 378 days after initial EECP. Of those who underwent repeat EECP, 70% had a decrease of >/=1 angina class at the end of repeat EECP with similar decreases in nitroglycerin use.
- Montori VM, Kavros SJ, Walsh EE, Rooke TW: Intermittent compression pump for nonhealing wounds in patients with limb ischemia. The Mayo Clinic experience (1998-2000). Int Angiol 21(4):360-6. 2002. BACKGROUND: The aim of this retrospective observational study was to review the use of an intermittent pneumatic compression device on nonhealing wounds in patients with critical limb ischemia at Mayo Clinic Rochester. METHODS: The setting was a community and referral multidisciplinary wound care clinic. The authors analysed 107 patients, median age 73, with critical limb ischemia and active ulcers started using a compression device between 1998 and 2000; 101 patients had lower extremity ulcers, and 25% had a history of amputation, and 64% had diabetes. Of all the wounds, 64% were multifactorial in etiology, and 60% had associated transcutaneous oxygen tension levels below 20 mmHg. Patients were typically asked to use the device at home on the affected limb(s) for 6 hours daily. The main outcome criterion was complete wound healing with limb preservation. RESULTS: The median follow-up after initiation of treatment was 6 months. Complete wound healing with limb preservation was achieved by 40% of patients with TcPO(2) levels below 20 mmHg; by 48% with osteomyelitis or active wound infection; by 46% with diabetes treated with insulin; and by 28% with a previous amputation. Half of all amputations occurred in patients with prior amputations. Seven patients discontinued the device because of pain experienced with its use. CONCLUSIONS: Patients with critical limb ischemia and nonhealing wounds at high risk of amputation can achieve complete wound healing and limb preservation by using an intermittent pneumatic compression device.
- Morgan RH, Carolan G, Psaila JV, Gardner AMN, Fox RH and
Woodcock JP: Arterial flow enhancement by impulse
compression. Vasc Surg 25: 8-15, 1991. Abstract: Preliminary
observations of rapid relief of ischemic rest pain following
application of a foot impulse compression device prompted this
study to quantify its immediate effects. Blood flow was calculated
by means of a duplex ultrasound imager interfaced with a Doppler
spectrum analyzer. Twelve normal subjects and 10 patients with
peripheral vascular disease (mean Doppler ankle/brachial systolic
pressure index = 0.62 (range 0.33-0.74) were studied. Mean resting
blood flow (SD) was not significantly different in the two groups:
55.6 24.0 in normal subjects and 48.3 29.8 in the arteriopaths
(p=>0.1). During five minutes of pump application in a 45-degree
foot-down position, mean popliteal blood flow increased 93% in the
normal group (p < 0.0001) and 84% in peripheral vascular
patients (p < 0.03); there was no change in the opposite limb.
In 5 normal subjects a "placebo" device produced no significant
change in flow (p > 0.1). In 4 patients with vascular disease
lying supine, impulse pumping produced no significant change in
flow (p > 0.1). It is suggested that the hyperemic effect may be
explained by the liberation of endothelial-derived relaxing factor
(EDRF), a powerful relaxant of vascular smooth muscle, produced in
response to sudden pressure changes (hemodynamic shear-stress)
within the venous system. Comments: This device "consisted of a
small portable pump and air reservoir that vents rapidly and
intermittently into a small pneumatic pad held around the foot by a
slipper (or beneath a cast). Inflation time was < 0.4 seconds,
inflation pressure was approximately 100 mm Hg with a three second
duration; the cycle was 20 seconds." This device is truly a "Mini"
device. The Mini-Boot of the Circulator Boot Systems, in contrast
compresses the entire leg beneath the knee for 0.34 seconds
commonly in end-diastole after every other heartbeat... thus,
delivering considerably more energy over a much larger
area.
- Niezgoda JA, McGuire M, Radke S, Reynolds G: Circulator Boot Therapy for Limb Salvage: The Milwaukee Experience – 300 Patients. SAWC 2011 Poster-Oral Abstract Presentation. (
SAWC 2011 Poster-Oral Abstract Presentation Submission. Abstract: Introduction: Peripheral arterial disease affects 12-20% of the U.S. population. Approximately 2% of these individuals have critical limb ischemia (CLI) and 25% of CLI patients will require major amputation within one year of diagnosis. Patients with CLI that develop forefoot gangrene are at highest risk for amputation despite successful revascularization, as there are limited options for treatment of small vessel disease.
Method: One treatment modality that has been used successfully in this group of patients is circulator boot therapy (CBT). CBT utilizes end diastolic pneumatic compression to improve arterial circulation in the leg, reverse tissue hypoxia and enhance wound healing. We analyzed of our database of over 300 patients that were managed with CBT. Our finding and results are reported.
Results: This is the largest single center reported series of patients treated with CBT. The majority of these patients presented with severe and end stage arterial vascular disease at significant risk for below knee (BKA) or above knee amputation (AKA). Limb salvage was defined as achieving complete healing, improvement or decrease in wound size sufficient to safely allow discontinuation of CBT, or single digit or distal partial foot amputation which allowed for nonprosthetic ambulation. Limb salvage was accomplished in over 70% of these patients.
Conclusion: Management of patients with CLI and forefoot gangrene is challenging and the risk amputation is high. Utilization of CBT can provide excellent results and prevent limb loss in select patients.(Comments: This clinic has operated with two Circulator Miniboots (treating from the tibial tuberosity to the toes) and one "B" Long Boot (designed to treat the whole leg in patients 63-69 inches in height...shorter folks take the "A" boot and taller the "C" boot.)
- Parmley WW, Chatterjee K, Charuzi Y, and Swan
HJC:Hemodynamic effects of noninvasive systolic unloading
(nitroprusside) and diastolic augmentation (external
counterpulsation) in patients with acute myocardial
infarction. Am J Cardiology 33: 819, 1974. Cardiac index
rose 17%, peak diastolic blood pressure rose 20mm Hg and mean
diastolic blood pressure rose 7mm Hg after external
counterpulsation. Changes in pulse rate, systemic vascular
resistance, right atrial pressure and pulmonary wedge pressure were
not significant. Stroke work index rose in the patients who had had
myocardial infarctions but not in controls.
- Pfizenmaier DH 2nd, Kavros SJ, Liedl DA, Cooper LT:
Use of intermittent pneumatic compression for treatment of
upper extremity vascular ulcers. Angiology 56:417-22, 2005.
Ischemic vascular ulcerations of the upper extremities are an
uncommon and frequently painful condition most often associated
with scleroderma and small vessel inflammatory diseases. Digital
amputation has been advocated as primary therapy because of the
poor outcome with medical care. Intermittent pneumatic compression
(IPC) pump therapy can improve ulcer healing in lower extremity
ischemic ulcerations; however, the value of this treatment in upper
extremity ischemic ulcerations is not known. This observational
pilot study consisted of a consecutive series of 26 patients with
27 upper extremity ischemic vascular ulcers seen at the Mayo Gonda
Vascular Center from 1996 to 2003. Inclusion criteria were
documented index of ulcer size and follow-up ulcer size and use of
the IPC pump as adjunctive wound treatment. Twenty-six of 27 ulcers
(96%) healed with the use of the IPC pump. Mean baseline ulcer size
was 1.0 cm2 (SD=0.3 cm2) and scleroderma was the underlying disease
in 65% (17/26) of cases. Laser Doppler blood flow in the affected
digit was 7 flux units (normal greater than 100). The mean ulcer
duration before IPC treatment was 31 weeks. The average pump use
was 5 hours per day. The mean time to wound healing was 25 weeks.
Twenty-five of 26 patients reported an improvement in wound pain
with pump use. Intensive IPC pump use is feasible and associated
with a high rate of healing in upper extremity ischemic ulcers. A
prospective, randomized, sham-controlled study of IPC is needed to
determine whether IPC treatment improves wound healing compared to
standard medical care. Comments: The patients here should have
been pleased with their success. Pumping an average of 5 hours a
day, they earned it. The "A" Circulator Boot can also be used to
treat upper arm ischemia and has especially found usage in the Bryn
Mawr Clinic among diabetic dialysis patients with areas of necrosis
in the fingers.
- Podrid PJ: Redefining the role of antiarrhythmic
Drugs. New Engl J Med 340:1910, 1999. First paragraph: "The
growing recognition of the potentially harmful effects of
antiarrhythmic drugs and the subsequent proof from controlled
trials that some of these drugs increase the risk of death in some
patients have led to a decline in their use. This change in
practice has been fueled by the widespread application of
nonpharmacologic therapies, such as implantable defibrillators and
radio-frequency catheter ablation, which have now become the
dominant types of therapy for many patients with ventricular and
supraventricular arrhythmias." Podrid then reviews two other
articles in the same journal issue, one describing success with
sotalol and the other with the short-acting drug ibutilide. He
concludes pointing out that authors did not recommend the routine
use of either sotalol or ibutilide, that the drugs should be used
when nonpharmacologic methods fail, and that drug therapy is
continuing to evolve.Comments: This article is included to take
the opportunity to discuss rhythm disturbances and booting. The
occurrence of rhythm disturbances in our boot population is common.
Patients with advanced peripheral arteriosclerosis obliterans may
be expected to have coronary heart disease predisposing them to
arrhythmias. The computer in the Circulator Boot monitor attempts
to adjust boot decompression to maximize cardiac output in patients
with atrial fibrillation (see Dillon, Angiology 1996 above). Still,
if the heart is irregular, so are boot compressions and such
irregularity is disturbing to both the patient and lay observers.
Setting the boot to pump on alternate beats tends to decrease the
irregularity. The 2:1 setting becomes a necessity if the heart rate
is rapid (over 120); with irregular rates between 90 to 120, the
2:1 setting is desirable. Commonly, we attempt to slow rapid atrial
fibrillation with either or both digoxin and a beta-blocker to
rates below 80. We have been pleased to find that a modest number
of patients may convert to normal sinus rhythm during their boot
therapy. It is possible that the improved hemodynamics described
above (Dillon, Angiology 1998) play a role. Another opportunity for
a study?
- Rajarama S-S, Shanahanb J, Ashe C, Waltersc AS: Enhanced external counter pulsation (EECP) as a novel treatment for restless legs syndrome (RLS): a preliminary test of the vascular neurologic hypothesis for RLS. Sleep Medicine 6:101-106, 2005. Abstract: Background and purpose: Enhanced external counter pulsation (EECP) is used to treat angina. With sustained treatment this increases collateral circulation to the coronary arteries as well as to the body as a whole. We found some patients who underwent EECP for angina or congestive heart failure who also coincidentally had severe Restless Legs Syndrome (RLS). Case reports are presented. Patients and methods: Six patients with RLS (1F, 5M, ages 55–80) underwent EECP treatment. All patients were given the International RLS Study Group rating scale for RLS (the IRLS) before and immediately after 35 days of EECP treatment. Results: The average IRLS rating scale score of the six patients before treatment was 28.8 (range 23–35), which indicates frequent and moderate to very severe RLS. After 35 days of EECP treatment the IRLS score was 6 (P<0.03), which indicates clinically insignificant RLS. Long-term follow-up in three patients indicates sustained improvement in all three at 3–6 months after EECP was completed (IRLS score 28.3–3.33). Further follow-up in four patients showed sustained improvement in two patients 1 year after EECP was completed. Conclusion: EECP improves RLS symptoms significantly and could be considered as an adjunct treatment for patients with RLS. In some cases, the improvement lasts for months after the course of treatment. In this way EECP is unique and unlike pharmacotherapy which requires continuous daily treatment. Furthermore, our results suggest that decreases in vascular flow influence the peripheral or central nervous system leading to the sensory symptoms of RLS. A larger number of patients studied under blinded conditions is needed to draw further conclusions.
Comments: The few patients we have seen with RLS have likewise been benefited with Circulator Boot therapy.
- Ramaswami G, D'Ayala M, Hollier LH et al: Rapid
foot and calf compression increases walking distance in patients
with intermittent claudication: results of a randomized
study. J Vasc Surg 41:794-801, 2005. OBJECTIVE: The aim of
our pilot study was to determine the usefulness of rapid,
high-pressure, intermittent pneumatic calf and foot compression
(IPCFC) in patients with stable intermittent claudication, with
reference to the end points of improvement in initial claudication
distance (ICD) (distance at which patient feels pain or discomfort
in the legs), and improvement in absolute claudication distance
(ACD) (distance at which patient stops walking because the pain or
discomfort becomes severe). METHODS: Thirty male patients
presenting with stable, intermittent claudication (ACD between 50
and 150 meters on treadmill testing at 3.8 km/h, 10 degrees
gradient) were recruited into this pilot study from a single
center. Fifteen patients were randomized to treatment with IPCFC
(applied for 1 hour twice daily in the sitting position) and were
also advised to have daily exercise, and 15 patients served as
controls, who were advised exercise alone. All patients received
aspirin and had resting and postexercise ankle/brachial index (ABI)
measured at enrollment along with ICD and ACD on treadmill testing
(3.8 km/h, 10 degrees gradient). The mean age, baseline ICD, and
ACD of the treatment and control groups were 70.4 +/- 7 years and
70.7 +/- 9 years, 55.8 +/- 15 meters and 68.4 +/- 17 meters, and
86.7 +/- 19 meters and 103.9 +/- 27 meters, respectively. Both
groups were equally matched for risk factors, including smoking,
type II diabetes mellitus, and hypercholesterolemia. IPCFC was
applied. The study protocol included follow-up visits at 1, 2, 3,
4, 6, and 12 months with the ABI, ICD and ACD being measured at
every visit. RESULTS: The percent change from baseline for ICD and
ACD for each patient visit and the mean +/- standard deviation
(SD), standard error (SE), and median were calculated for the
control and treatment groups. The percent change from baseline
measurements (mean +/- SD) for ICD and ACD in the control group at
4, 6, and 12 months were 2.2 +/- 18 and 2.3 +/- 18, 2.9 +/- 17 and
5.2 +/- 20, and 3.6 +/- 18 and 5.8 +/- 20, respectively. In
contrast, the changes in ICD and ACD at 4, 6, and 12 months in the
treatment group were 137.1 +/- 128 (P < .01) and 84.3 +/- 82 (P
< .01), 140.6 +/- 127 (P < .01) and 96.4 +/- 106 (P = .01),
and 150.8 +/- 124 (P <0.01) and 101.2 +/- 104 (P <0.01),
respectively. Although the ABI showed a slight increase in the
treatment group, these differences were not statistically
significant. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this pilot study show that
IPCFC improves walking distance in patients with stable
intermittent claudication. A significant increase in ICD and ACD
was seen at 4 and 6 months of treatment, respectively, and the
improvement was sustained at 1 year. The combination of IPCFC with
other treatment such as risk-factor modification and daily exercise
may prove useful in patients with peripheral arterial occlusive
disease. It may be a useful first line of therapy in patients with
disabling claudication who are unfit for major reconstructive
surgery. Improved walking on long-term follow-up and experience
from different centers may establish a role for this treatment
modality in the future. Comments: This study is included not
because of its size (15 patients in the treatment and control
groups) or the success of follow-up (6 treatment and 5 control at
one year), rather, it is included because the Aetna Insurance
company quotes it as one of a few studies supporting the
effectiveness of intermittent compression therapy in the treatment
of arterial disease. The treatment group had an average of 140%
improvement over their baseline walking distances while the control
group changed little. The treatment group was asked to pump two
hours a day in the ArtAssist equipment for over six months. The
latter inflated around the foot and calf rapidly to 120 mm Hg three
times a minute holding the pressure for three seconds each
compression or 9 seconds a minute. One must be careful with such an
apparatus in patients with advanced ischemia as shown by a reactive
hyperemia test requiring one to three minutes before the return of
the distal arterial pulses. In such patients, the 120 mm Hg
inflation pressure may be sufficient to expel both the arterial and
venous columns of blood from the leg and the interval between
compressions may not be sufficient to allow the arterial column to
be re-established. The Circulator Boot differs, of course, in
providing more compressions, in not expelling the arterial column
(the bag is placed to include a well-vascularized portion of the
leg), in not impeding arterial inflow during systole and in
providing concurrent cardiac support. The authors point out that
the rapid inflation of their boots may have stimulated the
endothelium to generate nitric oxide and prostacyclin. Such factors
likely have more local than systemic effects and in their patients
would be expected to have effects especially in the calf and foot.
In contrast, the Long Circulator Boot would be expected to generate
these factors throughout the leg and would further benefit patients
with occlusive disease above the knee.
- Shea ML, Conti CR, Arora RR: An update on ennhanced external counterpulsation. Abstract: The development of advanced revascularization techniques has resulted in the growth of a subset of patients with coronary artery disease who are nonrevascularizable and are considered to have refractory angina. Enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) has been developed for the management of these patients with chronic, refractory disease. Evidence has shown that through improvement of vascular endothelial function and recruitment of collateral vessels, EECP provides many clinical benefits. These patients experience sustained decreases in angina, improvement in exercise time, improved myocardial perfusion, and enhanced quality of life. Furthermore, EECP appears to be safe and effective in the treatment of angina in patients with impaired systolic function and has similar potential in patients with congestive heart failure. Comments: Those of us with experience with the Circulator Boot say amen.
- Shechter M, Matetzky S, Feinberg MS et al:
External counterpulsation therapy improves endothelial function in
patients with refractory angina pectoris. J Am Coll Cardiol
42:2096-8, 2003. OBJECTIVES: The goal of this study was to
investigate the influence of short-term external counterpulsation
(ECP) therapy on flow-mediated dilation (FMD) in patients with
coronary artery disease (CAD). BACKGROUND: In patients with CAD,
the vascular endothelium is usually impaired and modification or
reversal of endothelial dysfunction may significantly enhance
treatment. Although ECP therapy reduces angina and improves
exercise tolerance in patients with CAD, its short-term effects on
FMD in patients with refractory angina pectoris have not yet been
described. METHODS: We prospectively assessed endothelial function
in 20 consecutive CAD patients (15 males), mean age 68 +/- 11
years, with refractory angina pectoris (Canadian Cardiovascular
Society [CCS] angina class III to IV), unsuitable for coronary
revascularization, before and after ECP, and compared them with 20
age- and gender-matched controls. Endothelium-dependent brachial
artery FMD and endothelium-independent nitroglycerin (NTG)-mediated
vasodilation were assessed before and after ECP therapy, using
high-resolution ultrasound. RESULTS: External counterpulsation
therapy resulted in significant improvement in post-intervention
FMD (8.2 +/- 2.1%, p = 0.01), compared with controls (3.1 +/- 2.2%,
p = 0.78). There was no significant effect of treatment on
NTG-induced vasodilation between ECP and controls (10.7 +/- 2.8%
vs. 10.2 +/- 2.4%, p = 0.85). External counterpulsation
significantly improved anginal symptoms assessed by reduction in
mean sublingual daily nitrate consumption, compared with controls
(4.2 +/- 2.7 nitrate tablets vs. 0.4 +/- 0.5 nitrate tablets, p
<0.001 and 4.5 +/- 2.3 nitrate tablets vs. 4.4 +/- 2.6 nitrate
tablets, p = 0.87, respectively) and in mean CCS angina class
compared with controls (3.5 +/- 0.5 vs. 1.9 +/- 0.3, p <0.0001
and 3.3 +/- 0.6 vs. 3.5 +/- 0.5, p = 0.89, respectively).
CONCLUSIONS: External counterpulsation significantly improved
vascular endothelial function in CAD patients with refractory
angina pectoris, thereby suggesting that improved anginal symptoms
may be the result of such a mechanism.
- Schleicher SM and Milstein HJ: Treatment of
pretibial mucinosis with gradient pneumatic compression.
Arch Dermatol 130:842-844, 1994. Authors successfully treat an 83
year old man with multiple flesh-colored-to-erythematous indurated
nodules and plaques over both anterior tibial areas. He also had
non-pitting edema and a continuois drainage.
- Silverglade A: Peripheral vascular disease:
diagnosis and treatment by passive vascular exercises. Arch
Physical Therapy 21:100, 1940. Describes success with
suction-pressure boot in the pre-antibiotic era.
- Smith PC, Sarin S, Hasty J and Scurr JH:Sequential
gradient pneumatic compression enhances venous ulcer healing: A
randomized trial. Surgery 108: 871-875, 1990. Abstract: The
treatment of venous ulcers has remained largely unchanged for
centuries. The application of properly applied graduated
compression bandages, the use of graduated compression stockings,
and surgery have been shown to achieve healing. However, some
ulcers persist despite appropriate management. A randomized study
was undertaken to compare two regimens of treatment for such
patients. Both regimens included ulcer debridement, cleaning,
nonadherent dressing, and graduated compression stockings. In one
regimen, sequential gradient intermittent pneumatic compression was
applied for 4 hours each day. Only one of 24 patients in the
control group had complete healing of all ulcers compared with 10
of 21 patients healed in the intermittent pneumatic compression
group. The median rate of ulcer healing in the control group was
2.1% area per week compared to 19.8% per week in the intermittent
pneumatic compression group. The results indicate that sequential
gradient compression is beneficial in the treatment of venous
ulcers. Comments: Dillon (Angiology 1986) reported successful
treatment with the Circulator Boot in 17 patients with refractory
stasis ulcers. In his recent report on 2177 legs (Angiology 1997),
there were 155 with difficult venous problems; 144 were healed or
improved. Several had but a few treatments and were lost to
followup. Many of these patients had tried other compression boots.
The Circulator Boot, of course, delivers more energy to the leg
than the usual sequential pneumatic boot; it compresses the leg
forcefully after each heartbeat and tends to soften the leg.
- Solignac A, Ferguson RJ and Bourassa MG: External
counterpulsation: coronary hemodynamics and use in treatment of
patients with stable angina pectoris. Cath and Cardiovas
Diag 3: 37-45, 1977. During ECP peak early and mean arterial and
diastolic BP's significantly raised above control value by 32 and
14% respectively. But coronary sinus blood flow, LV O2 consumption,
LV lactate extraction, mean systolic arterial BP, and cardiac index
not significantly altered by ECP. Concluded ECP of doubtful value
in Rx of patients with stable angina. Comment: Cardiassist
apparatus (Medical Innovations Inc, Waltham, Mass) used. Leg
pressures of 200-250 applied during the first two-thirds of
diastole without attention paid to releasing the legs at a moment
to maximize unloading of the left ventricle during systole. Indeed,
their figure 1 shows presystolic brachial artery pressure to be
higher during ECP than in the control period. While their peak
diastolic blood pressure about matched systolic peak pressure, it
was not in the very high range noted to be necessary in balloon
angioplasty to dilate arteriosclerotic lesions.
- Soran O, Kennard ED, Kfoury AG, Kelsey SF, IEPR Investigators: Two-year clinical outcomes after enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) therapy in patients with refractory angina pectoris and left ventricular dysfunction (report from The International EECP Patient Registry). Am J Cardiol 97(1): 17-20, 2006. Enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) is a noninvasive circulatory assist device that has recently emerged as a treatment option for refractory angina in left ventricular (LV) dysfunction. This 2-year cohort study describes the long-term follow-up of patients who had severe LV dysfunction that was treated with EECP for angina pectoris and reports clinical outcomes, event-free survival rates, and the incidence of repeat EECP. This study included 363 patients who had refractory angina and LV ejection fraction < or =35%. Most patients reported quality of life as poor. After completion of treatment, there was a significant decrease in severity of angina class (p < 0.001), and 72% improved from severe angina to no angina or mild angina. Fifty-two percent of patients discontinued nitroglycerin use. Quality of life improved substantially. At 2 years this decrease in angina was maintained in 55% of patients. The 2-year survival rate was 83%, and the major adverse cardiovascular event-free survival rate was 70%. Forty-three percent had no reported cardiac hospitalization; 81% had no reported congestive heart failure events. Repeat EECP was performed in 20% of these patients. The only significant independent predictor of repeat EECP in a proportional hazard model was failure to complete the first EECP treatment course (hazard ratio 2.9, 95% confidence interval 1.7 to 4.9). Improvements in angina symptoms and quality of life were maintained at 2 years. In conclusion, for patients who have high-risk LV dysfunction, EECP offers an effective, durable therapeutic approach for refractory angina. Decreased angina and improvement in quality of life were maintained at 2 years, with modest repeat EECP and low major cardiovascular event rates.
- Soroff HS, Hui J and Giron, F.: Current status of
external counterpulsation. Critical Care Clinics 2:277-295,
1986. Authors review history and various applications of ECP. Point
out that the "Cardiassist" is the only apparatus used in the USA
and that it provides external pressure over a limited portion of
the thigh and leg..."in actual practice"..."over the lower third of
the thigh". Conclude inclusion of the large upper thigh muscles
crucial. Suggest that depressurization to atmosphere pressure as
opposed to a negative pressure may be associated with a rise in
systolic pressure possibly because of increased cardiac output and
venous return. Various reports of ECP reviewed: Myocardial
infarction, cardiogenic shock and angina. Except for the studies of
Zheng below, most of these studies utilized courses of treatment of
but a few hours. In summary, authors conclude improved treatments
would include 1. treatment area to include the buttocks; 2.
technique to include a negative pressure phase; 3. further
investigation of graded sequential approach with negative phase; 4.
treatment earlier in cardiogenic shock and for at lease 4 hours in
cardiogenic shock. Comment: Circulator Boot therapy may include
most of the thigh and is commonly done for many hours. Except for
Dillon's (1998 above) small study on hemodynamics and RST changes
on the Holter monitor, no formal studies have been organized for
the use of the Circulator Boot in the treatment of cardiac
disorders. Still, many of our leg patients have heart disease and
in them we have had apparent success in individual patients with
chronic congestive heart failure and angina. Further, we have seen
pain relief in patients with an acute MI. Anecdotal measurements
providing evidence for cardiac benefit have included: reduction of
the loudness of mitral insufficiency murmurs; widening of the
peripheral pulse tracing with leg pumping during systole; narrowing
of the tracing with end-diastolic pumping; raising the dicrotic
notch with systolic pumping and lowering it with end-diastolic
pumping; and in patients with a Swann-Gans catheter in place,
lowering wedge pressure and increasing cardiac output.
- Steinberg J: Cardiosynchronous limb compression:
effects on noninvasive vascular tests and clinical course of the
ischemic limb. Angiology 43:453-61, 1992. Abstract: Some
patients with chronic arterial obstruction of the limbs may still
suffer the consequences of advanced tissue ischemia, including
ulceration and rest pain, and face threatened limb loss in spite of
available surgical, pharmacologic, and other treatments. Additional
therapeutic modalities were thus sought to accomplish limb salvage.
A literature review indicated that most reports on R-wave-triggered
circumferential limb compression (cardiosynchronous limb
compression [CSC]) demonstrate its ability to augment limb arterial
blood flow and improve ischemic limbs. To determine the device's
efficacy and safety, and possibly confirm earlier positive reports,
a systematic study was undertaken, using older, as well as newer,
more electronically reliable CSC devices. The present study was
designed to determine the following: 1. objectively, by noninvasive
vascular tests, changes in limb blood flow, if any, by CSC; 2.
clinical effects of CSC, if any, on the ischemic limb; 3. duration
of CSC-induced limb improvements, if any; 4. side effects or safety
of CSC. The study demonstrated that CSC treatments: 1. caused
increased limb blood flow as determined by increased ankle/arm
indices and hallux photoplethysmograph waveform amplitudes during
treatments; 2. led, in most cases, to improvement in or resolution
of the presenting ischemic problem (eg, ulcer, cellulitis, rest
pain); 3. induced limb improvements that persist for up to seven
years 4. caused no adverse side effects.
- Stevenson LW: Inotropic therapy for heart
failure. N Engl J Med 339:1848-1850, 1998. In this
editorial, Dr. Stevenson reviews the various inotropic agents
(dopamine, dobutamine, pirbuterol, xamoterol, milrinone,
pimobendan, flosequinan and, in the same issue of the New England
Journal, vesarinone) and concludes all increase mortality rates
versus placebo. Digoxin, she points out has a neutral effect on
mortality. Current approved therapy, she concludes consists of
diuretics and angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors.
Comment: Circulator Boot therapy has long been approved by the FDA
in the treatment of patients with congestive heart failure. Dr.
Dillon in unpublished data has noted what he calls the "marathon
run effect". In explaining this effect, he suggests that the reader
is running the Boston Marathon and keeping pace with a runner above
his/her ability. The runners start up "heartbreak hill". The
trained runner readily climbs the hill while the reader/runner
becomes breathless and faint in the attempt to keep up. Would the
breathless runner benefit from digoxin or dopamine? No, he/she
would stop running and walk until he/she had recovered. Would the
runner/reader then go home and quit the race. No, most likely he
would resume the race and take more care with pace of running. What
does the patient do when daily life becomes "heartbreak hill". Our
patients "may walk" for forty minutes while they are in the
Circulator Boot. After the treatment, they then "resume the race"
and go home. Many of these patients can be kept compensated if they
are booted 40 minutes three times a week. We are hoping others will
avail themselves of this benefit of booting. Even more, we are
hoping that some group will be interested in performing a clinical
trial to document the benefit and its duration.
- Sultan S, Esan O, Fahy A: Nonoperative active management of critical limb ischemia: initial experience using a sequential compression biomechanical device for limb salvage. Vascular 16: 130-9, 2008. Critical limb ischemia (CLI) patients are at high risk of primary amputation. Using a sequential compression biomechanical device (SCBD) represents a nonoperative option in threatened limbs. We aimed to determine the outcome of using SCBD in amputation-bound nonreconstructable CLI patients regarding limb salvage and 90-day mortality. Thirty-five patients with 39 critically ischemic limbs (rest pain = 12, tissue loss = 27) presented over 24 months. Thirty patients had nonreconstructable arterial outflow vessels, and five were inoperable owing to severe comorbidity scores. All were Rutherford classification 4 or 5 with multilevel disease. All underwent a 12-week treatment protocol and received the best medical treatment. The mean follow-up was 10 months (SD +/- 6 months). There were four amputations, with an 18-month cumulative limb salvage rate of 88% (standard error [SE] +/- 7.62%). Ninety-day mortality was zero. Mean toe pressures increased from 38.2 to 67 mm Hg (SD +/- 33.7, 95% confidence interval [CI] 55-79). Popliteal artery flow velocity increased from 45 to 47.9 cm/s (95% CI 35.9-59.7). Cumulative survival at 12 months was 81.2% (SE +/- 11.1) for SCBD, compared with 69.2% in the control group (SE +/- 12.8%) (p = .4, hazards ratio = 0.58, 95% CI 0.15-2.32). The mean total cost of primary amputation per patient is euro29,815 ($44,000) in comparison with euro13,900 ($20,515) for SCBD patients. SCBD enhances limb salvage and reduces length of hospital stay, nonoperatively, in patients with nonreconstructable vessels.
- Topol EJ: Coronary-artery stents --- gauging,
gorging and gouging. N Engl J Med 339:1702-1703, 1998. This
editorial was written to accompany two other articles on stenting
coronary arteries. The interested reader is encouraged to seek out
the editorial itself. Here are some excerpts: ..."Coronary stenting
is now the predominant form of nonsurgical myocardial
revascularization and accounts for well over 60 percent of the
percutaneous coronary revascularization procedures performed in the
United States"... "The widespread use of stents by cardiologists
predates the strong evidence provided by recent trials and probably
reflects a response to angiographic gratification ( the x-ray image
of a large, smooth arterial lumen ( which a colleague and I have
called the 'oculostenotic reflex'. Cardiologists have mistakenly
believed that stenting reduced the incidence of death and
myocardial infarction. However, careful examination of the results
of randomized trials comparing stenting with balloon angioplasty,
including the trial by Erbel et al, shows an excess number of
deaths and myocardial infarction among patients assigned to
stents"...." To date, the only clinical benefit that has been shown
for stenting, as compared with balloon angioplasty is a reduced
need for target vessel revascularization."...."Unfortunately, in
hospitals throughout the United States today, patients with lesions
in small arteries, bifurcations, and extensive, diffuse
atherosclerotic disease undergo stenting even though there are no
data to support these applications". Comments: The cautious and
critical elements of this editorial are included to provide those
interested in using booting in the treatment of heart disease with
information as to the limitations and hazards of various invasive
techniques. Patients with peripheral arterial occlusive disease are
almost certain to have coronary disease. We find that it is not
uncommon for them, even though asymptomatic, to find their way to
the invasive cardiologist who may perform an angioplasty with or
without stenting. Quite commonly the balloon impacts plaque into
the origin of a small artery producing a small infarct, which in
the belief that a larger infarct may have been prevented by the
procedure, is not reported to the patient. On occasion, the patient
does not survive the procedure.
- Tschakovsky ME, Shoemaker JK, Hughson RL: Vasodilation and muscle pump contribution to immediate exercise hyperemia. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 271: H1697-H1701, 1996. Abstract:
A rapid (within 0-5 s) increase in skeletal muscle blood flow has been demonstrated following muscle contraction, yet the mechanism remains unresolved. Recently, it was suggested that the entire rapid exercise hyperemia could be attributed to the mechanical muscle pump effect. Other evidence indicates that the muscle pump cannot increase arterial flow. We measured human forearm blood flow with the arm positioned above or below heart level during 1) simulation of rhythmic muscle pump function via repeated inflation/deflation of a forearm cuff to 100 mmHg to achieve mechanical emptying of forearm veins, and 2) 1-s single-cuff inflations, 1-s voluntary forearm contractions, and 1-s contractions performed within a cuff inflation. Rhythmic cuff inflation increased blood flow with the arm below heart level (P < 0.05) but not above. Flow following single contractions was higher than flow following cuff inflation within 2 s (P < 0.05). Peak flow increases due to a single mechanical venous emptying (7.7 +/- 0.7 ml.100 ml(-1) min(-1)) could account for 60% of the peak flow increase due to muscle contraction (12.8 +/- 1.0 ml.100 ml(-1).min(-1)) with the arm below heart level, whereas above heart level mechanical venous emptying accounted for 46% of the flow increase due to contraction (3.0 +/- 0.4 vs. 6.5 +/- 0.6 ml.100 ml(-1).min(-1)). We conclude that a functional muscle pump does exist in the human forearm in vivo, but that a rapid vasodilation detectable within 2 s also contributes to the early exercise hyperemia. Comments: We endeavor to have the leg/foot well below heart level in treating peripheral vascular insufficiency with the Circulator Boot. Conditions associated with swelling (venous stasis and lymphedema) on the other hand, may be treated in the supine position.
- van Bemmelen PS, Mattos MA, Faught WE, Mansour MA, Barkmeier
LD, Hodgson KJ, Ramsey DE, Sumner DS: Augmentation of
blood flow in limbs with occlusive arterial disease by intermittent
calf compression. J Vasc Surg 19:1052-8, 1994. Authors'
conclusions: An increased arteriovenous pressure gradient accounts
for some but not all of the flow increase, much of which must be
attributed to transient vasodilatation. Because the increase in
flow does not depend on an increased inflow pressure and was not
adversely affected by a low resting ankle-brachial pressure index
or a low toe-pressure, intermittent external limb compression may
deserve investigation as a possible adjunct to the nonoperative
treatment of patients with severe arterial insufficiency.
Comments: A transient benefit during a single treatment in this
study. Patients with Circulator Boot treatments have long-lasting
benefits after a series of treatments.
- van Bemmelen PS, Gitlitz DB et al: Limb salvage using high-pressure intermittent compression arterial assist device in cases unsuitable for surgical revascularization. Arch Surg 136:1280-5, 2001. HYPOTHESIS: Intermittent compression therapy for patients with inoperable chronic critical ischemia with rest pain or tissue loss may have beneficial clinical and hemodynamic effects. STUDY DESIGN: Case series of 14 consecutive ischemic legs that underwent application of a 3-month treatment protocol during a 2(1/2)-year study. SETTING: Veterans Administration Hospital. PATIENTS: Thirteen patients with 14 critically ischemic legs (rest pain, n = 14; tissue loss, n = 13) who were not candidates for surgical reconstruction were treated with rapid high-pressure intermittent compression. The patients had a mean age of 76.2 years, 8 were diabetic, and they represented 10% of referrals for chronic critical ischemia. They were not amenable to revascularization owing to lack of outflow arteries (n = 7), lack of autogenous vein (n = 5), or poor general medical condition (n = 3). INTERVENTION: All patients were instructed to use the arterial assist device for 4 hours a day at home for a 3-month period. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Limb salvage and calibrated pulse volume amplitude. RESULTS: After 3 months, 9 legs had a significant increase in pulse-volume amplitude (P< .05). These legs were salvaged, whereas the 4 amputated legs demonstrated no hemodynamic improvement. We noted a direct correlation between patient compliance and clinical outcome. Patients in whom limb salvage was achieved used their compression device for longer periods of time (mean time, 2.38 hours a day) compared with those who underwent amputation (mean time, 1.14 hours a day) (P< .05). These mean hours of use were derived from an hour counter built into the compression units. CONCLUSIONS: Intermittent high-pressure compression may allow limb salvage in patients with limb-threatening ischemia who are not candidates for revascularization. Further studies are warranted to assess intermittent compression as an alternative to amputation in an increasingly older patient population. Comments: Of the 45 articles KCI has on their website on the benefits of the Artassist, this is the only one finding its way to publication that involves limb salvage. Most involve improvement in vascular tests or the benefits seen in claudication patients; several of these are included above.
- Vella A, Carlson LA, Blier B, Felty C, Kuiper JD and Rooke
TW: Circulator boot therapy alters the natural history of
ischemic limb ulceration. Vascular Medicine 5:21-25,
2000.(Mayo Clinic & Foundation, Rochester, MN) Abstract:
Despite numerous advances in interventional radiology and vascular
surgery, the clinician continues to be confronted with inoperable
vascular disease. Previous studies have shown that ulceration
associated with a transcutaneous oxygen pressure (tcPO2) of <20
mmHg is refractory to all attempts at healing. External pneumatic
compression for the treatment of peripheral vascular disease has
been available for several years, although there is a relative
paucity of data regarding its role in clinical practice as well as
its efficacy. The objective of this study was to examine the
experience with circulator boot therapy in the treatment of
ischemic ulcers in the absence of osteomyelitis, and specifically
to determine whether such therapy can be of benefit in ischemic
limb ulceration associated with a tcPO2 of ><20 mmHg. A
retrospective chart review was undertaken of all patients with a
lower limb ulcer who, in the absence of osteomyelitis, underwent
circulator boot therapy at the Gonda Vascular Center. A total of 98
patients was identified. Two patients died within one month of
commencing therapy and were not included in further analysis. The
tcPO2 data were unavailable in five patients. Outcome in the
patient population was classified as favorable if (1) healing was
achieved, (2) the ulcer decreased in size, or (3) the affected limb
improved sufficiently to allow successful revascularization. An
unfavorable outcome was one where a major amputation was performed
or where the ulcer increased in size. Out of a total of 29 patients
with a tcPO2 <20 mmHG at the area of ulceration, 19 had a
favorable outcome following circulator boot therapy. Of the
remaining 62 patients with a tcPO2 >20 mmHG, 54 had a favorable
outcome. Circulator boot therapy is associated with improved
outcomes in limb ulceration due to peripheral vascular disease.
Complete ulcer healing as well as preservation of the affected limb
can be achieved in most cases. Comments: This study was
accomplished at the Gonda Vascular Center at the Mayo Clinic. We
are, of course, pleased with the favorable outcome of their study,
but we had some misgivings when they undertook it. Mayo is a well
known referral center that attracts patients from great distances.
Many of these patients do not have the time or money to stay at
Mayo many weeks and, as our case history section illustrates,
difficult cases with advanced disease may require many weeks to be
cured. It was quite possible that a study at Mayo might be negative
because the patients were booted too briefly to have a clinical
effect. Indeed, some of their patients were not healed at the time
of discharge. In an attempt to further help these patients, they
utilized non-cardiosynchronous home pump therapy in an identical
percentage of patients in each of their outcome categories. They
noted that in this study (which was not designed to study the
effects of home therapy), this therapeutic modality did not seem to
have additional benefits on the outcome of ischemic limb ulceration
after Circulator Boot therapy.
- Vijavaraghavan K, Santora L, Kahn J et al: New graduated pressure regimen for external counterpulsation reduces mortality and improves outcomes in congestive heart failure: a report from the Cardiomedics External Counterpulsation Patient Registry. Congest Heart Fail 11:147-52, 2005. External counterpulsation (ECP) has been shown to increase exercise tolerance and reduce angina episodes, Canadian Cardiovascular Society Functional (CCSF) class, anginal medication usage, and hospitalizations in refractive CCSF class III and IV stable angina. However, the high pressures and resulting 1.5:1-2:1 peak diastolic to peak systolic pressure (D/S) ratios shown to be optimal in the treatment of angina can cause excessive preload and adverse effects in congestive heart failure (CHF) patients, particularly those with left ventricular ejection fractions <40%. Data were retrospectively analyzed from the Cardiomedics ECP Registry on 127 New York Heart Association (NYHA) class II-IV CHF patients (79.6% men; average age +/- SD, 68.2+/-15.6 years), with a comorbidity of CCSF class III-IV refractive angina, who were serially treated with 35 hours of ECP (1 h/d, 5 d/wk for 7 weeks) at unconventionally low pressures and D/S ratios under a new graduated pressure regimen. The pressures and D/S ratios were gradually increased in stages over the 7-week ECP regimen. The patients were divided into three groups based on the pressures applied and the resulting average D/S ratios (Low, Mid, and High). In the Low D/S ratio group (average D/S ratio 0.7:1), all-cause mortality in the year following ECP treatment was only 1.85% (one of 54 patients), whereas over the same time period in the Mid D/S ratio group (average D/S ratio 1.08:1), all-cause mortality was 7.69% (three of 39 patients) and in the High D/S ratio group (average D/S ratio 1.32:1), all-cause mortality was 8.82% (three of 34 patients). For the Low, Mid, and High D/S ratio groups, respectively: 1) average left ventricular ejection fractions increased 23.0%, 20.1%, and 17.5%; 2) NYHA class declined 36.6%, 29.6%, and 29.6%; and 3) all-cause hospitalizations, including terminal admissions, were reduced 85.7%, 82.6%, and 57.1% in the year following ECP therapy from the prior year. There were no adverse effects or withdrawals from the ECP therapy and no significant difference in sex-based outcomes. Consequently, ECP applied at low pressures and average D/S ratios of 0.7:1 under the new graduated pressure regimen is safe and effective in the treatment of CHF and produces a significant reduction in mortality, compared with the 8.5% annualized mortality of the Multicenter Automatic Defibrillator Implantation Trial II (MADIT II) (N=1232) of NYHA class II-III CHF and the 12.2% annual mortality of the Comparison of Medical Therapy, Pacing, and Defibrillation in Heart Failure (COMPANION) study (N=595) of NYHA class III-IV CHF. Lower pressures improve patient comfort and may encourage more CHF patients to seek treatment. The reduction in hospitalizations should significantly reduce the cost of treating CHF. Comments: The ECP people are learning that the pressures utilized in the Circulator Boot are more effective than their previously used high pressures. Next, they need to learn about the advantages of end-diastolic pumping, avoiding pressure gradients up the leg, and anticipating the next heartbeat.
- Waggoner PC: Mechanical interventions after acute
myocardial infarction: impact on patient outcome. Critical
Care Nursing Clinical if N Am 4:359-363, 1992. Listed possible
outcomes for patients with acute myocardial infarction: ISCHEMIC
PHASE - prevent permanent myocardial necrosis, reduce myocardial
oxygen consumption, restore adequate coronary artery circulation,
relieve pain and discomfort and prevent dysrhythmias;
INFARCT/NECROSIS PHASE - reduce infarct size, maintain adequate
tissue perfusion, prevent complications, relieve pain and
discomfort and prevent extension of infarction; and RECOVERY PHASE
- promote maximum functional capacity, prevent further loss of
functional myocardium and reduce risk factors. Criteria for total
ventricular support: mean arterial pressure < 60 mm Hg; left
atrial and/or right atrial pressure < 20 mm Hg, urine output
< 20 ml/hr; cardiac index < 2L/min/M2 with: (a) maximum
pharmacological therapy, (b) optimal preload (right atrial and left
atrial pressures 15-20 mm Hg) and (c) intra-aortic balloon pump (if
appropriate).
- Werbel GB and Shybut GT: Acute compartment
syndrome caused by malfunctioning pneumatic-compression boot, a
case report. J Bone and Joint Surgery 68-A:1445-1446, 1986.
Jobst boot valve failed allowing leg compression at 40 mm Hg for 9
hours during surgery. Comments: Such an adverse outcome might be
possible with the long Circulator Boot if (a) therapy was continued
for many hours and (b) a fold of the plastic bag functioned as a
flutter valve letting air into the boot but blocking its
venting.
- Werner D, Hui JC, Kropp J, Daniel WG: Pneumatic
external counterpulsation -- a therapy option in angina
pectoris. Zeitschrift fur Kardiologie 87 suppl 2: 193-8,
1998. Abstract: Pneumatic external counterpulsation operates by
applying ECG-triggered diastolic pressure via cuffs to the vascular
bed of the lower limbs. Comparable with intra-aortic balloon
pumping, PECP produces a diastolic augmentation combines with
increase of mean arterial pressure and coronary perfusion.
American, Asian, and our own data demonstrated a reduction of
angina pectoris through repeated use of PECP one or two hours daily
for four to seven weeks. Exercise testing and thallium scanning
confirmed the clinical improvement. PECP is a virtually risk-free
treatment option in patients suffering from angina despite medical
and interventional treatment. Opening of collaterals and collateral
growth induced by external counterpulsation are discussed as the
cause of clinical benefit.
- Werner D, Michelson G et al: Changes in ocular blood flow velocities during external counterpulsation in healthy volunteers and patients with atherosclerosis. Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol 239:599-602, 2001. BACKGROUND: External counterpulsation (ECP) is a new noninvasive means of augmenting organ perfusion by applying ECG-triggered diastolic pressure to the vascular bed of the lower limbs. In this study, effects of ECP on changes of ocular blood flow velocities were studied. METHOD: Mean, systolic and diastolic flow velocities of the ophthalmic artery were measured by Doppler sonography before and during ECP. Twelve healthy volunteers (age 31.3+/-4.3 years) and 12 patients with severe atherosclerosis (inclusion criteria: two atherosclerotic risk factors, at least one severe coronary stenosis, age 62.1+/-5.3 years) were included in the study. RESULTS: In healthy subjects, ECP changed diastolic flow velocity of the ophthalmic artery nonsignificantly from 21.6+/-7.7 to 23.7+/-10.5 cm/s. Systolic flow velocity decreased significantly from 36.1+/-13.6 to 28.9+/-10.2 cm/s (P<0.01). Mean flow velocity changed nonsignificantly from 28.1+/-9.4 to 26.5+/-9.9 cm/s. In atherosclerotic patients, mean flow velocity increased significantly from 26.3+/-11.4 to 29.3+/-11.2 cm/s (P<0.001), which was caused by significant diastolic flow augmentation from 19.7+/-9.1 to 23.9+/-9.7 cm/s (P<0.001). Systolic flow velocity was not changed significantly (from 34.2+/-12.8 to 32.6+/-11.8 cm/s). CONCLUSION: No significant change of mean blood flow velocity in the ophthalmic artery was found in young healthy subjects. In elderly patients with atherosclerosis, ECP significantly increased blood flow velocity in the ophthalmic artery by 11.4%. This may indicate an ocular perfusion benefit in these patients as a result of ECP and could also explain the increase of perfusion found in patients with retinal ischemia after ECP.
- Werner D, Michalk F, Hinz B, Werner U, Voigt JU, Daniel WG: Impact of enhanced external counterpulsation on peripheral circulation. Angiology 58: 185-190, 2007. Enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) is a noninvasive counterpulsation technique that reduces angina and improves exercise capacity in patients with coronary artery disease. Diastolic coronary perfusion is augmented by pneumatic compression of 3 sets of cuffs wrapped around the lower extremities. Although central hemodynamic changes are well investigated, almost no data exist about the changes of peripheral circulation during EECP. In this study, 12 patients with angina and angiographic evidence of coronary artery disease were treated for 1 hour with EECP. In these patients, peripheral artery disease was excluded by duplex sonography. The patients rested 1 hour before EECP in supine position, and they remained in that position for 1 hour after the procedure. Changes of flow volumes and flow pattern of the posterior tibial artery and the brachial artery were measured by sonography at the end of all 3 periods. Furthermore, we measured the concentration of circulating prostanoids at these 3 time points. Averaged flow volume of the posterior tibial artery decreased to 69% +/- 23% (P < .05) during EECP and increased to 133% +/- 34% (P < .05) of baseline 1 hour after the procedure. In contrast, the averaged flow volume of the brachial artery increased by 9% +/- 4% (P < .05) during EECP and returned to baseline values after EECP. The flow pattern of the posterior tibial artery showed a second early diastolic antegrade flow caused by the cuff inflation and a reverse end-diastolic flow after the deflation of the cuffs. These flow changes caused an increase of the pulsatility index by Gosling (397% during EECP), returning to baseline values in the recovery period. Plasma concentrations of circulating prostanoids showed no significant change during EECP. Thus, pedal flow volume decreased to approximately two thirds of baseline during EECP followed by reactive hyperemia even 1 hour after the procedure; however, this decreased perfusion triggered no change of the prostacyclin/thromboxane ratio and was well tolerated by all investigated patients. The observed 4-fold increase of the peripheral pulsatility index supports the thesis of increase of shear-stress-related improvement of endothelial function during EECP. Comments: Here average flow decreased 69% during EECP and these patients were thought to have no peripheral vascular disease. Hui in his 2006 patent (US 7,048,702 B2 on ECP assigned to Vasomedical Inc) notes that a pressure drop of 10-30 mmHg is preferred between the various cuffs with pressures of 160 to 300 mmHg being applied to the distal cuffs and 160 to 250 being applied to the proximal cuffs to "milk" the peripheral blood back up the vascular tree. The standard reactive hyperemia vascular laboratory test reminds one how dangerous these pressures might be in patients with the peripheral vascular disease that commonly accompanies those with ASHD. In the test anoxia is produced by putting a tourniquet on the thigh for three minutes and then recording the time required for a Doppler pulse to return to the posterior tibial. In patients with advanced arteriosclerosis obliterans in whom the distal flow is derived through collaterals that first nourish the musculature before re-entering the tibial vessels, the time required may be a matter of minutes. In such patients significant leg ischemia may be anticipated throughout any ECP treatment.
- Werner D, Michalk F et al: Accelerated reperfusion of poorly perfused retinal areas in central retinal artery occlusion and branch retinal artery occlusion after a short treatment with enhanced external counterpulsation.. Retina 24:541-7, 2004.BACKGROUND: To date, no satisfactory therapy has become available for patients with acute central retinal artery occlusion (CRAO) or branch retinal artery occlusion (BRAO). Enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) is a new noninvasive procedure that increases perfusion of inner organs. In the current study, the authors measured the impact of EECP on reperfusion in ischemic retinal tissue. METHODS: In a prospective, randomized study, 20 patients with CRAO or BRAO were included. Ten patients were given hemodilution therapy and 2 hours of EECP, and 10 patients were given regular hemodilution therapy only. Quantification of changes in retinal perfusion was carried out by means of scanning laser Doppler flowmetry (in arbitrary units). RESULTS: Enhanced external counterpulsation caused no observable adverse events. A significant increase in perfusion occurred immediately after EECP in the ischemic retinal areas (57 +/- 19 arbitrary units versus 99 +/- 14 arbitrary units). In contrast, no change was measured in the group not treated with EECP (83 +/- 19 arbitrary units versus 89 +/- 44 arbitrary units). Forty-eight hours later, a significant increase in perfusion could be shown in the ischemic retina of both groups, and no significant difference of perfusion was found between the two groups any longer. CONCLUSION: The current study suggests that EECP could be a clinically useful and safe procedure in patients with CRAO or BRAO to accelerate recovery of perfusion in ischemic retinal areas.
- Williams DO, Korr KS, Gewirtz H and Most AS:The
effect of intraaortic balloon counterpulsation on regional
myocardial blood flow and oxygen consumption in the presence of
coronary artery stenosis in patients with unstable angina.
Circulation 66: 593-597, 1982. Six patients studied.
Counterpulsation treatment with the intraaortic ballon decreased
the rate-pressure product and aortic-end diastolic pressure; and
the peak systolic aortic pressure and regional myocardial oxygen
consumption declined in 5 of the 6 patients. Peak and mean aortic
diastolic blood pressures increased. Changes in regional coronary
blood flow paralleled changes in peak systolic aortic presssure
(P< 0.007). Thus, relief of angina during IABP could not be
ascribed to an increase in regional coronary blood flow. Reduction
of myocardial oxygen consumption was thought to be the most likely
mechanism by which IAPB relieves myocardial ischemia in patients
with unstable angina. Nine patients were actually studied but the
thermodilution catheter could not be placed in two and one could
not be satisfactorily pumped. The data on the remaining six
patients comprise the report. Five of the 6 had an insignificant 5%
fall in peak systolic pressure; the five also had a 56% rise in
peak diastolic pressure, a 17% rise in mean diastolic pressure, a
21% fall in end-diastolic aortic pressure and a 14.1% drop in
myocardial O2 consumption. In their discussion, the authors noted
that coronary flow may go up in shock patients as it is diminished
by the low aortic pressure. Comments: This article is included
because it is commonly quoted in textbooks of cardiology and
illustrates how thin the data is that points to a significant
hemodynamic effect for the aortic balloon.
- Yu S, Da H and Zhen Z: External Counterpulsation,
Review Article. Chinese Med J 103(9): 768-771, 1990. ECP
available in 1800 medical units. A 3 stage sequential ECP
controlled by a microprocessor. ANGINA PECTORIS: 1. Short term:
symptoms in 52.6% of 3218 cases significantly improved, 30.3%
improved, 8% no change and 0.2% deteriorated. In 5067 cases, the
EKG had significant improvement in 20.5%, improved in 47.8%, did
not change in 30.5% and deteriorated in 1.2%. 2. Long term results
likewise were significantly better in ECP group versus a placebo
medication group. MORTALITY in angina patients: ECP vs placebo in
1st and 8th years: 4.9 vs 13.51 (1st year) and 7.69 vs 30.3 (8th
year). TREATMENT OF ISCHEMIC CEREBRAL DISEASES: in small series ECP
more effective than medication. OTHER APPLICATIONS: Effective in
87.2% of cases of sudden deafness. Effective in treatment of
thrombus of the retinal artery, traumatic optic atrophy, and serous
central retinopathy. Comment: Effect of ECP largely attributed
by author to rise in diastolic pressure presumably promoting
collateral blood flow in various tissues. Similar successes have
been seen in small numbers of patients treated with the Circulator
Boot without the same amount of increase in diastolic pressure and
have been attributed to other factors such as an increase in the
level of circulating fibrinolysins.
- Zheng Z-s, Li T-m, Kambic H, Chen G-h, Yu L-q, Cai S-r, Zhan
C-y, et al: Sequential external counterpulsation (SECP)
in China. Trans Am Soc Artif Intern Organs 29: 599-603,
1983. Previous apparatuses which raise diastolic augmentation but
26-32% unsatisfactory while studies raising DA 59-104% effective.
Here DA raised 43.9% higher than obtained with 4-limb SECP alone.
Unique features of this apparatus: synchronized with heartbeat and
follows pulse rate; a series of solenoids activated at 50 msec
intervals; a screen displaying the ECG, the signals to the solenoid
valves, and an earlobe plethysmography; a deflation of premature
beats; balloon pressures of 265mm distally, 240 proximally, and 200
on the buttocks; and an exhaust system that empties "before the
heart enters systole" to reduce afterload. 97% of 200 angina
patients relieved with improved EKG in 63.8% and little relapse
when Rx stopped (40 controls treated with Segontin had relief in
72.5% and improved EKG's in 40%, half relapsing after drug
stopped). In 52 patients with an acute MI, 95.7% relieved of pain
within a few hours and 5.8% dies vs mortality of 18.4% in 152
controls. When the effects of SECP were evaluated with the mapping
method of Maroko et al, the ZST and NST indicators of infarct size
were found to increase in the control group and decrease in the
SECP group. Comment: This boot is used in supine position
negating effect of gravity in reducing afterload.
Return to CBC
Homepage
Return to
Menu of Medical Literature
Clotting
Factors, Vascular Hormones and Ischemic Disease


